ABOUT WADEEMAIL WADEFACEBOOKTWITTERPODCASTFREE IPHONE APPRSSJUMP TO VIP BLOGVIP LOG-IN VIP SIGN-UPGO TO PWTORCH.COM



PWTORCH.COM
JUMP BACK TO PWTORCH.COM

Listen to the PWTorch Livecast Mon-Fri Listen live or subscribe via iTunes

 


WK EDITORIAL 6/30: Spike TV rebranding and refocusing - how this could be good news for TNA

Jun 30, 2011 - 4:04:15 PM


Bookmark us!

StaffKeller08_120_32.jpg
BY WADE KELLER, PWTORCH EDITOR

The Attitude Era is over. TNA seems to be living in a time warp, though, trying to go back in time and recreate that. Last Thursday's Impact, particularly the first hour, shows that TNA is still trying to relive the past. The Attitude Era worked because of:

-Steve Austin's unique breakout character, and what a contrast it was to Hulk Hogan and Bret Hart before him.

-The Mr. McMahon character, after decades being the straight-laced announcer and the unstated leader of the company, shocked people with is 180 degree turn into the mad boss.

-Degeneration X being a younger, more cool version of the rapidly over-expanded, growing-tired NWO group. Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Chyna, X-Pac, Road Dogg, and Billy Gunn were younger, fresher, and more in-your-face than the NWO was. Their skits going after WCW at the Georgia HQs sent a message that WCW didn't have the market cornered on edgy factions with star power.

-The fact that for decades before the Attitude Era, wrestling was very different, much more conservative, much more PG - especially the Hulk Hogan-to-Bret Hart years of the WWF, therefore the Attitude Era felt new and fresh, unlike anything that mid-'90s to late-'90s audience had grown up watching.

TNA isn't breaking new ground with their raunchy, tawdry language and angles and close-ups of women's crotches as they enter the ring. They just look pathetic and desperate to be cool, and that's just not going to happen with the creep-factor of Mike Tenay acting all turned on by the women and Eric Bischoff informing us of when he "took a leak" last week.

TNA's excuse for taking this approach has been that Spike TV is targeted primarily toward men 25-49. They figure if they themselves pigs, all men are pigs, so let's cater to their sleazy tendencies to want all things raunchy and lewd and sexist.

===
(Here's my blog from last Thursday night listing the tawdry aspects of just the first hour of Impact Wrestling last week: WK QUICK BLOG 6/24: In the first hour of TNA Impact last night, we heard this... - http://pwtorch.com/artman2/publish/wadekellerdotcom/51012.shtml)
===

The problem is no man 25-49 wants to spend two hours on Thursday nights with programming that seems to be written on a laptop by some sad, lonely, miserable woman-hating writer in a dank, dark corner of the trashiest, sleaziest strip club on the outskirts of town. That's how TNA comes across too often.

People have seen the Attitude Era, and it worked because of DX, Steve Austin, Mr. McMahon, along with The Rock and Mick Foley and a dose of contemporary athleticism unlike anything in WWE previously with the Hardy Boyz and Edge & Christian.

Mr. Bischoff is no Mr. McMahon, and even if he was, it'd feel like a weak derivative to those who had seen the real thing. Mr. Anderson is no Stone Cold, and even if he was, it'd feel like a rerun to those who had seen the real thing.

If Spike TV begins selling advertisers on a wider demo that includes younger men, teens, and especially women - which is sounds like they're aiming to do this year - that is good news for TNA. It will be that outside impetus for them to shift away from this tired, tawdry formula and move toward entertaining people with a product that is more upbeat, less derivative, and certainly less sexist. They can be sexy without being sexist. They can be titillating without being sleazy. They can even be horny without being creepy. They can present women as strong, independent athletes who just happen, in many cases to be attractive rather than "skanks and sluts who can't get along."

TNA Impact drives away women. It's not just because they're on Spike TV. Sure, WWE is on a woman-friendly network, so that explains to a degree why Raw does around a 1.1/1.2 rating for women compared to Smackdown doing only a 0.5/0.6 on SyFy. But Impact on Spike is 0.2 or less - not even ranking in the top 50 in any female demographic for its night on television.

UFC is also on Spike. It's men really hitting each other and bleeding. It's violent. There are no female characters on the show other than the "ring girls." You'd think Impact would do better than UFC on the same network, right? Wrong. UFC draws 0.5/0.6 ratings among that women demo, more than double or triple TNA Impact's female demo audience.

If TNA portrayed women with respect and even reverence, and if they didn't celebrate the "male pig" as the epitome of manliness, maybe they could expand that overall audience from the 1.1, give or take, they've been stuck at for years, despite massive increases in payroll and (aging) star power, expensive billboards in Times Square, the expansion of social media helping good products catch fire quickly, and the additional years to in build on their base audience.

Changing the tone and the theme of their show doesn't mean it can't be edgy. It just shouldn't be tawdry and pathetic and sad and dirty and sexist and excessively violent. And Impact Wrestling, more often than those in charge realize, comes across that way. This change wouldn't solve everything, as they still have to shore up the efficiency of the booking and the lack of admirable heros and despicable villains battling each other in situations where there's a clear reason to root for one over the other.

If they clean up their show, they might not only attract more women over the course of the next year, but more men who want to watch it now will be able to watch it in the same room as their girlfriend or wife. Whether the woman in the room is actually watching or is instead surfing the internet next to their boyfriend, they will at least be able to tolerate being in the room when Impact is on (you know, like UFC and Smackdown).

Not only that, but if they cut back on the valuable TV time given to the 50+ crowd (Eric Bischoff, Hulk Hogan, Sting) and the 40+ crowd (Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle, Rob Van Dam) and focus more on younger wrestlers that their younger viewers can relate to, they might draw back some of those teen viewers that Bischoff and Hogan have turned away in the last year.

Five months ago, Impact was drawing nearly triple the male teens they're drawing now. Those are Impact Wrestling's future 18-34 year olds and 25-54 year olds. Earning their loyal viewing now can pay off as they age into the relevant advertising demographics. Close ups of Bischoff's gray hair and aging angry face, both in the ring and in his office, segment after segment, talking about "taking a leak" and brow-beating the younger "bad ass" wrestlers into retreating out of his office with their heads hanging isn't appealing to male teens or women.

So if Spike TV changes direction, it could be the impetus for change that TNA should have made a long time ago. Quit narrowly focusing on viewers who either like the "male pig" sexist aspects of the show or at are willing to at least plug their noses and tolerate it while waiting around for some good wrestling and hope that younger characters will some day become the centerpiece. TNA has the roster right now to build exclusively around wrestlers and characters under 40, and with good booking the talent they have is sufficient to improve on the 1.1 they currently are drawing.

Is there a place for Sting? Yes, as a once or twice a year special mystery partner a young babyface brings in to help him fend off a faction of heels. Is there a role for Hulk Hogan? Perhaps, as a babyface "law and order" enforcing commissioner who appears once every 2-3 weeks in a special circumstances that commands everyone's attention because when he appears on TV, something big is about to be announced.

I understand Bischoff and Hogan are positioning themselves as central characters so that they stay relevant and seem indispensable and thus remain on Panda Energy payroll as on-air characters, but I think TNA would be better off with a sharp turn away from their well-earned reputation as a landing pad for WWE rejects and older wrestlers ready to cash in on their star power and coast for a while, earning their last money in pro wrestling.

Here's our original story on this, including details from a cable analyst who attended the conference and filed a report for us. This is very much worth reading...

LINK: TNA News: Spike TV formally discusses re-branding, promotes shows other than Impact at media presentation, what the re-branding means for TNA

Web visitors, comment below. App users, email your thoughts to kellerwade@gmail.com or visit the "desktop version" of my blog to read and contribute reader comments: www.wadekeller.com.


Please Recommend or Like This Article on Twitter or Facebook


CLICK HERE to return to Wade Keller Blog home page

CLICK HERE to jump to PWTorch.com's main page

MORE RECENT WK BLOG ARTICLES...
KELLER BLOG: Paul Heyman alliance with C.M. Punk - where does it go from here?
KELLER'S WWE SUMMERSLAM PPV BLOG: Results and analysis throughout the show including Lesnar vs. Triple H, Cena vs. Punk vs. Show
KELLER: C.M. Punk is not best utilized as a tweener, despite a recent reader poll; he should be all out heel

Comment on this Article Below


THE TORCH AND USA TODAY PRESENT THIS EXCLUSIVE UFC VIDEO FEATURE


GO VIP - GET ENHANCED BLOG + MORE!

PWTorch VIP Members get an ad-free enhanced version of this blog including a reader comment area with Wade Keller's conversation with readers after each blog. Sign up for a VIP membership and get 60+ VIP Audio Shows, New PWTorch Weekly Newsletter Digital Edition, 100s of PWTorch Newsletter Back Issues, Ad-Free Access to Entire PWTorch Site, PWTorch VIP Forum, Many Special Archive Features, and More! SIGN UP HERE

LATEST PWTORCH ARTICLES
NEWS REPORTS
WWE NEWS: WWE uses "get well" message for Daniel Bryan to promote Network announcement instead; super-imposes McMahon on Smackdown broadcast
WWE NEWS: Sports Legacy Institute confirms Triple H on Board of Directors; Chris Nowinski comments
WWE NEWS: WWE addresses legal action against the company in SEC filing - what did WWE say about the TV contract lawsuits & Billy Jack Haynes's suit?
NEWSWIRE: Sonnen claims $5 million WWE offer, WWE star at World Series parade, release date for WWE Christmas movie, Cena grants wish, Del Rio & TNA stars in Japan, Elgin, more
WWE NEWS: Non-Spoiler matches for Halloween Smackdown
CALDWELL'S WWE SMACKDOWN TV TAPING REPORT: In-person coverage of "Halloween" Smackdown TV taping (with no Vince McMahon message that aired on Smackdown)
WWE NEWS: WWE reveals U.K. launch date for WWE Network
WWE NETWORK: Friday, October 31 Halloween Schedule
TNA NEWS: Impact quarter-hour TV ratings - details on Wednesday's episode fared with a TNA Title main event
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in - how did TNA fare against World Series Game 7?
WWE NEWS: How did the stock market respond to WWE's latest quarterly earnings report?
ROCK NEWS: Fortune runs big profile on The Rock - WWE return?, steroid use?, future in movies & TV, more
PPV REPORTS
HIAC PPV VOTING: Poll Results for Overall Rating, Best Match, was the Bray Wyatt ending too screwy?
MCNEILL'S PPV BLOG 10/26: Live Blog for Hell in a Cell - ongoing thoughts & observations
CALDWELL'S WWE HIAC PPV REPORT 10/26: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live PPV - double Hell in a Cell main event of Ambrose vs. Rollins and Cena vs. Orton
CALDWELL'S WWE HIAC PPV REPORT 10/26 (Pre-Show): Miz TV, Paul Heyman on the panel, more
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - TNA Bound for Glory: Best/Worst Match, What Will Be Remembered?, Updated 2014 Rankings
PPV RESULTS - 10/13 New Japan in Tokyo, Japan: Styles drops IWGP World Hvt. Title to Tanahashi, more title changes, former WWE star returns to New Japan, more
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - Night of Champions: Best/Worst Match, Surprise/Letdown, Updated 2014 PPV Rankings, and a message to WWE on making PPV buyers feel like morons
ROH "ALL-STAR EXTRAVAGANZA" ROUNDTABLE: Radican, Metzger, Leahy rate & review ROH's most-recent show
MCNEILL'S PPV BLOG 9/21: Live Blog for Night of Champions - ongoing thoughts & observations
CALDWELL'S WWE NOC PPV REPORT 9/21: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live PPV - Lesnar vs. Cena
CALDWELL'S WWE NOC PPV REPORT 9/21 (Pre-Show): Christian's Peep Show with Jericho, Roman Reigns injury update
CALDWELL'S NEW JAPAN PPV RESULTS 9/21: Complete live coverage of "Destruction in Kobe" - Nakamura regains IC Title, Tanahashi vs. Shibata, A.J. Styles, new Jr. Hvt. champion, more
TV REPORTS
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 10/31: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of the Halloween episode, including Divas Costume Battle Royal, Dean Ambrose vs. Cesaro in Trick-or-Street Fight
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 10/30: Kidd vs. Cara main event, Summer faces Emma in Divas action
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 10/30 - Week 124: Zayn vs. O'Neil main event, battle royal, more; Overall Reax
TNA IMPACT RESULTS 10/29: Lashley vs. Roode for the TNA Title, tournament continues, KO heel turn, more
10/29 LUCHA UNDERGROUND TV REPORT (EPISODE #1): Prince Puma vs. Johnny Mundo (Morrison), Konnan, Ezekiel Jackson, Vampiro, Matt Striker
DEHNEL'S WWE MAIN EVENT REPORT 10/28: Miz TV double trouble, Bo Dallas faces U.S. champ, Paige vs. Natalya
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 10/27: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Hell in a Cell fall-out, Cena vs. Rollins, Ambrose responds to Bray Wyatt, two title matches, Hulk Hogan, more
METZGER'S ROH TV REPORT 10/26: All ROH Titles on the line on "Championship Week," including Briscoe vs. Bennett
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 10/24: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Friday show, including Dolph Ziggler vs. Cesaro for the Intercontinental Championship
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 10/23: Swagger vs. Bo Dallas main event, plus Kofi vs. Kidd
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 10/23: Neville defends NXT Title against Titus O'Neil, Tyler Breeze, Ascension, more; Overall Reax
TNA IMPACT RESULTS 10/22: TNA Title match contract signing, Tag Tournament begins, hardcore match, more
OPINION & ANALYSIS
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 10/31: Could a point system work in WWE? Should WWE create a Botchmania special hosted by Mike Adamle? How big of a problem is WWE announcers not selling heels cheating? WWE Magazine shutdown?
SD POLLS 10/31: Vote on your favorite thing from Halloween Smackdown & WWE using Bryan chants for Network pitch
VALLEY: The story behind the 1980s wrestler who is suing WWE for egregious mistreatment of its wrestlers over the years
GUEST REVIEWS: Lucha Underground - perspective from TV taping, editorial on strengths & weaknesses of first episode
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STARS 10/30: Is Cena too Super? Is Goldberg vs. Cena in the cards in the future? Why did the WWE Magazine cease publishing? When did a wrestler land on your radar as “one to watch?"
RADICAN: An independent solution to WWE's stagnant mid-card; Thoughts on WWE PPV finishes, Final Battle, WWNLive in China
LUCHA UNDERGROUND POLL: Vote on the series premiere
LIVECAST POLL: Who should be ranked #1 in the PWI 500?
PARKS'S TAKE: The Raw TV Main Event Plague, plus thoughts on Lucha premiere, tonight's Impact, Chamber PPV's proper slot, more!
QOTD REAX #3: More feedback on whether WWE gets a pass for non-finishes on Network Era PPVs
VOTE: What do you plan to watch tonight on television?
ASK THE SPECIALISTS ROUNDTABLE: Who will John Cena face at WrestleMania 31?
THE SPECIALISTS
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: PWTorch Exclusive Interview - Toy Designer Talks New ROH Action Figure Line
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest Rankings & Evaluation of the roster heading toward "Takeover" special
HITS & MISSES - 10/27 WWE Raw: Henry Turn, Cena - Authority, Ambrose - Wyatt, Cena vs. Rollins
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Where to Find Trading Cards of Lucha Underground’s Top Stars
TUCKER LIVE AT HIAC: Instant Reaction to Sunday's PPV
VALLEY'S TAKE: Wrestling Fans Are Frustrated, But Why?, Plus Random Thoughts on RKO Vines, Triple H, more
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest Evaluation of WWE prospects, plus play along with the Drake Younger hashtag
10/20 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Miz & Mizdow, Orton - Cena - Heyman,, Mick Foley, Rusev - Big Show, Ambrose and a Mannequin
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Batista’s Star-Making Role Has Collectors Chasing His "Guardians" Cards
TUCKER'S RAW INSTANT REACTION: "This Hell in a Cell sure is dangerous ... now time for a joke"
VALLEY'S TAKE: Who are these guys? Fans aren't given enough information to be fully emotionally invested in today's WWE stars, plus Random Thoughts
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest NXT Rankings & Evaluation of WWE's top prospects
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
WWE RAW FIVE YEARS AGO: Triple H vs. Big Show main event, John Cena on his feud with Randy Orton: "The rivalry needed to end, and it did!"
WWE NEWS FIVE YEARS AGO - Shane McMahon shocks wrestling industry by resigning from WWE
WCW WEDNESDAY: Nitro episode airing today on WWE Network - Ric Flair vs. Hulk Hogan on live Nitro
10 YRS AGO: Ring of Honor event in Chicago features Punk vs. Samoa Joe one hour draw, plus Delirious, Sydal, Nigel, Jacobs, Shelley, Homicide
WWE RAW 5 YEARS AGO: WWE forces Raw vs. Smackdown feud leading to Bragging Rights, plus Snoop Dogg, Triple H vs. John Cena, Marty Jannetty, more
10 YRS AGO - WWE Live Event - 10/19/2004 in Minneapolis: Undertaker vs. JBL in main event among worst main events ever, Big Show vs. Angle, Carlito vs. Eddie, Taker vs. Heidenreich
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 Climax 23: Day 1" report 8/1/13 - Suzuki-Nagata, Tanahashi-Kojima, Okada-Devitt main event
RADICAN'S "The Kevin Steen Show with Gabe Sapolsky" review - fatherhood, lessons learned after being fired from ROH, launching EVOLVE, Heyman, inside the Steen-Generico-Briscoes feud
RADICAN'S CHIKARA King of Trios 2014: Night 2 report 9/20 - Rey De Voladores mini-tournament begins, Spud, Sanda, Tatsu in action, Flood-Colony main event
20 YRS AGO: Report on WWE house show at Bourne High School headlined by Bulldog vs. Owen, Razor Ramon vs. Backlund, plus Adam Bomb, Volkoff, bundy, Doink, Gunns
10 YRS AGO: Reader Reax to Oct. 14, 2004 edition of Raw with Ric Flair, RVD, Austin, Steiner, RVD, Shawn Michaels, Goldberg, Bishoff
20 YRS AGO: Cactus vs. Sabu headlines NWA event - pioneering hardcore style match with moonsault onto table, plus Al Snow
REFERENCE
TNA NEWS: Impact quarter-hour TV ratings - details on Wednesday's episode fared with a TNA Title main event
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in - how did TNA fare against World Series Game 7?
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - how did the post-Hell in a Cell episode fare versus the NFL?
WWE NEWS: Total Divas viewership for Sunday's mid-season finale; overall performance of Season 3
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - Friday's show gets clobbered against World Series
TITLES & CHAMPS: Ongoing list of 2014 Titleholders
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in for Wednesday's show
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in for Monday's show - how did the HIAC lead-in episode fare?
WWE NEWS: Total Divas continues Sunday night slide
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in for Friday's show
TNA NEWS: Impact TV quarter-hour ratings - details on this week's show sliding to near-low on Wednesday nights
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Monday's show rebounds from year-low, but there is a concerning demo & viewership pattern
PWTorch Free Podcast
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/31) now available - Keller talks live w/John Piermarini
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (10/30) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (10/29) now available - Pat McNeill & the All-Star Panel
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (10/28) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (10/27) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Special PWTorch Livecast following HIAC PPV now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/24) now available - Wade Keller talks live w/Sean Waltman
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (10/23) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (10/22) now available - McNeill w/wrestling author Paul O'Brien
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (10/21) now available - Wade Keller takes live calls
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (10/20) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/17) now available - RVD Interview w/Wade Keller
VIP Exclusive Features
VIP - 10/31 Moonlighting with Greg Parks: With PWTorch contributor Justin James, discussing the latest episodes of Smackdown, NXT and Superstars (48 min.)
VIP - 10/31 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Should WWE consider moving PPVs from Sundays to Tuesdays? Who are possible WrestleMania 31 opponents for Seth Rollins? Are heel commentators necessary in this era? Ross? Ventura? (29 min.)
VIP - 10/31 AD-FREE PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow w/John Piermarini: Ex-Creative Team member takes listeners inside booking meetings with Vince McMahon, plus how are expenses covered for writers on the road, Bray angle (43 min.)
VIP - 10/31 Audio Flashback - Keller's WWE No Mercy Post-PPV Show (10-03-2004): Cena vs. Booker T in U.S. Title five match series, Undertaker vs. JBL for WWE Title, Show vs. Angle, plus Eddie, Rey, RVD, Kidman, Dudleys, Dawn Marie (37 min.)
VIP - 10/30 Bruce Mitchell Audio Show w/Wade Keller, pt. 1: So now what? WWE Network numbers are in and it's time for WWE to reevaluate some ways of doing business to fix what's wrong and build on what's right (62 min.)
VIP - 10/30 Wade Keller Hotline - WWE Network Update: Full analysis and perspective on today's third quarter data on WWE Network subscribers, what the numbers mean, where it goes from here (30 min.)
VIP - 10/30 PWTorch Livecast: James Caldwell & Greg Parks: In-depth discussion on WWE Network & business standing, fixing biz by fixing the "core product," is McMahon right person to lead in Network Era?, new TNA champ, Lucha premiere, more! (120 min.)
VIP - 10/29 East Coast Cast (ep. #214): Rollins up, Ambrose down, WWE continues to use heels to pitch products, Henry's heel turn, Network subs, more!; VIP Conversation (189 min.)
VIP - 10/29 PWTorch Livecast: Pat McNeill & All-Star panelists Al Castle of PWI & Scott Fishman of the Miami Herald: PWI 500 insight, this week in wrestling, more!; VIP - News & Events & live SD TV taping perspective (99 min.)
VIP - 10/29 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Did Cena need to equate WWE to being a "cause" on his promo on Raw? Why is it bad for WWE biz to have Triple H & Steph as on-air heels? Is it time for Network specials on territory days? (30 min)
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1378 (PDF & TEXT): Keller's Hell in a Cell PPV Report and Torch Staff PPV Roundtable Reviews, Pg. 2 Radar on Billy Jack Haynes suing WWE, Mitchell on WWE's varied clientele, Parks on the Class of 2002
VIP - 10/28 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Ratings news, time to elevate second tier wrestlers into top tier stars, MSG line-up reveals Rusev's next feud, Post-Raw happenings, WWE's latest fan survey, Network predictions (14 min.)
© 1999-2011 TDH Communications Inc. • All rights reserved. -- PRIVACY POLICY