PWTORCH.COM

Select List of Articles by Category Type

SEARCH PWTORCH



CONTACT US

 JUMP TO VIP SITE

VIP SIGN-UP INFO

JUMP TO MMATORCH

UGO AFFILIATE

A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999


PWTorch is customized for your mobile phone such as your Blackberry. Just enter www.pwtorch.com on your phone's browser and choose the "Mobile" option. Samsung Omnia II users, download our free Widget. Apple iPhone users, download our free PWTorch App (search "pwtorch")



 

CALDWELL'S TAKE

CALDWELL: The real story on Eugene (Nick Dinsmore) is not questionable TV content, but Dinsmore himself

Feb 12, 2010 - 11:56:42 AM


Staff08Caldwell_120c_169.jpg
By James Caldwell, Torch assistant editor

Much has been made lately about the "Eugene" mentally-challenged character that was introduced on WWE TV in April 2004.

Videos have circulated to Connecticut media members interested in former WWE CEO Linda McMahon's Senate race showing classic, fun-for-all-ages WWE video clips such as Eugene being destroyed by Triple H in a steel cage.

Hartford Courant's Rick Green even went to McMahon's Senate campaign HQ looking for answers from McMahon herself.

"There was never any intent of WWE to make fun of anyone who is developmentally challenged in any way," McMahon said. "It was to show how you can rise above your circumstances. He always had this quality of believing he could be anything he wanted to be. It's a soap opera. It's all a matter of taste."

McMahon added: I don't want you to mischaracterize what my judgment is. Eugene was an example of the different kinds of issues that can be addressed in life. Here was a fellow who really believed who he was and there were no obstacles to him. It portrayed an element in life that gave hope and inspiration to others."

Ah, yes, the "subjective analysis" of WWE programming argument. It's a disarming argument that calms the issue and doesn't grab headlines or inspire voters to sway one or the other.

What might sway voters or at least expose a scar WWE has tried to cover is the real story about the real person who played the Eugene character.

Eugene was played by Nick Dinsmore, who was a three-strikes-and-you're-out victim of the Wellness Policy. Dinsmore dealt with prescription painkiller addiction while with WWE.

"I always rationalized it as my back hurts, my knee hurts, I can't go out there and perform in pain, so I have to do something about it," Dinsmore said in a February 2009 interview. Read the story.)

Even more troubling was WWE sending Dinsmore on an international tour in late 2005 just days after the death of his close friend, Eddie Guerrero, whose death rushed along the implementation of the current Wellness Policy.

Torch columnist Bruce Mitchell wrote in December 2005 about Dinsmore's pain pill addiction escalating at the time and WWE using him as an example weeks after Guerrero's death.

Nick Dinsmore, who considered Eddie Guerrero a close friend and mentor ever since he recommended him for a spot on the main roster, was not allowed to go to the funeral. Instead, he was forced to make the immediate, arduous trip to England, where he was expected to act out his on camera mentally impaired always happy Eugene character anytime he was seen in public. He made it less than a week, then passed out in a hotel lobby from an overdose of Soma pain pills. He was immediately suspended and sent to rehab. Because of PR considerations in the wake of Guerrero's death, Dinsmore's condition and its consequences were immediately made public in a way that had never happened before.

The real stories in Linda McMahon's Connecticut Senate race are not on the surface with TV content, characters, and storylines. Sure, they're part of the dialogue that has to be included because WWE's TV programming reaches impressionable children who still point to their crotches and yell "suck it!" on school buses (just ask my wife, who teaches Pre-K), but the real stories are below the surface.

Dinsmore's story is not the "Eugene" character, but the prescription pain pills, following "the show must go on" mentality following yet another wrestler death that is still prevalent in today's wrestling industry, and pushing his body when it never should have been pushed.

McMahon has yet to account for the real story on a former WWE star after easily talking down the surface-level story.


Send feedback on this article to pwtorch@gmail.com and we'll regularly publish reader feedback in the "Torch Feedback" category on the Main Listing.

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA...
VISIT OUR AFFILIATE - PROWRESTLING.NET

For UFC & MMA NEWS & BLOGS:
VISIT OUR SISTER SITE - MMATORCH.COM

Upgrade to PWTorch VIP:

 DETAILS & SIGN-UP INFO (VIP Newsletter, Audio, Archives, No Ads on Website, VIP Email Reports, VIP Forum, more.)

More Recent CALDWELL'S TAKE Articles
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.

STAFF PICKS - TOP TEN RECENT ARTICLES
WEEKEND LIVE RESULTS: Cena vs. Rusev in a cage, PWG title changes, AIW tournament, more
LIVECAST AUDIO: Jim Ross talks live w/Wade Keller on Thursday's Livecast - now available on-demand
LATEST WWE NEWS: Samoa Joe makes NXT debut, Rock teases WM32 return, big news week, more
LATEST TV REPORTS: Parks's Smackdown Report, NXT Takeover & Lucha Underground, Raw, Impact, more
WWE PPV COVERAGE: Full Results & Reports from Payback - Caldwell, McNeill, more



PWTORCH FREE AUDIO SHOWS
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (5/22) available on-demand - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Jim Ross talks live w/Wade Keller on Thursday's Livecast - now available on-demand
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (5/20) available on-demand - McNeill's All-Star Panel w/FAIRPLAY & Scott Fishman
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (5/19) available on-demand - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (5/18) available on-demand - Raw post-game show w/James Caldwell & live callers
LIVECAST AUDIO: Special PWTorch Livecast (5/17) Payback post-game show now available on-demand - James Caldwell & Greg Parks

PWTORCH INSTANT POLL
SD POLL 5/21: Vote on Thursday's Smackdown episode
 
pollcode.com free polls


SD POLL 5/21: What was the Best Match on Smackdown?
 
pollcode.com free polls
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL 5/20: Who will be NXT Unstoppable's "Star of the Night" after this evening's show?
 
pollcode.com free polls
CHAMBER PPV POLL: Which WWE Tag Title team would you like to be stuck in a pod with?
 
pollcode.com free polls
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

UPCOMING MAJOR EVENTS

SELECT LIST OF ARTICLES BY CATEGORY

ARTICLES GROUPED BY CATEGORY
NEWS REPORTS
WWE NEWS: Raw TV tonight - Elimination Chamber lead-in, "Entourage" guest stars, final Raw at Nassau Coliseum, more
WWE NETWORK: Monday, May 25 Schedule - Daniel Bryan DVD preview post-Raw, Tough Enough marathon, more
SHOW RESULTS - 5/24 WWE in White Plains, N.Y.: Cena vs. Rusev steel cage wraps the tour, Tag Title match takes best match honors, Harper & Rowan hit 3D, more
SHOW RESULTS - 5/24 AAA "Lucha Libre World Cup" in Mexico City: AAA Dream Team of Rey & Alberto & Sin Cara in finals, plus teams from TNA, ROH, Lucha Underground, Japan
WWE/UFC NEWS: Ronda Rousey offers latest comment on potential WWE return, plus talks "intimidating" WrestleMania debut
SHOW RESULTS - 5/23 WWE in Worcester, Mass.: Cena vs. Rusev in a steel cage - who did Lana help on this show?, local promos, more
WWE NEWS: Betting odds released on ... 2016 Royal Rumble?, who are early favorites?
WWE NEWS: TMZ - WWE stars join wedding reception post-house show
WWE WEEKEND TOUR - Sunday in New York: Cena in a steel cage, WWE champ on second tour (Reports Wanted)
SHOW RESULTS - 5/23 AIW J.T. Lightning Tournament Night 2 in Cleveland, Ohio: Samoa Joe wrestles post-NXT debut, Ray Rowe wins, more
EVENT REPORT - 5/23 "Roundhouse Revival" in Memphis, Tenn.: Jerry Lawler wrestles at Mid-South event (w/Pics)
SHOW RESULTS - 5/23 "Tribute to Women's Wrestling" in Wilmington, N.C.: NWA Women's champ wins tournament in front of Trish & Lita & more legacy stars
PPV REPORTS
MCNEILL'S PPV BLOG 5/17: Live Blog for WWE Payback 2015 - ongoing thoughts & observations
CALDWELL'S PAYBACK PPV REPORT 5/17: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of four-way WWE Title match, I Quit War, more
CALDWELL'S WWE PAYBACK PPV REPORT 5/17 (pre-show): R-Truth vs. Stardust, Ascension vs. nostalgia pairing, more
RADICAN'S ROH/NJPW "GLOBAL WARS 2015" iPPV REPORT 5/15: Bullet Club vs. ROH All-Stars main event, Okada vs. Alexander, more!
METZGER'S ROH VS. NEW JAPAN IPPV REPORT 5/15: Bullet Club vs. Team ROH mega-main event, Lethal defends TV Title, top NJPW stars in action, Chris Sabin, Addiction, more
RADICAN'S NJPW "Wrestling Donkatu 2015" Report 5/3: Omega-Shelley, Kingdom-Bullet Club, Nakamura-Goto
SHOW RESULTS - 5/3 NJPW'S "Wrestling Dontaku 2015" in Tokyo, Japan: Nakamura vs. Goto IC Title main event, new IWGP Jr. Tag Champs, Omega-Shelley, Styles, more
RADICAN'S EVOLVE 41 iPPV REPORT 4/17 - Busick-Perkins, Richards-Gargano, Strong-Thatcher 2/3 Falls main event
MCNEILL'S PPV BLOG 4/26: Live Blog for WWE Extreme Rules 2015 - ongoing thoughts & observations
CALDWELL'S EXTREME RULES PPV REPORT 4/26: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live PPV - Rollins vs. Orton steel cage, Cena vs. Rusev, Last Man Standing, more
CALDWELL'S EXTREME RULES PPV REPORT 4/26 (pre-show): Complete coverage of Barrett vs. Neville, Dean crashes set, more
RADICAN'S KING OF INDIES 2015 REPORT 3/27 - Night 1: First round tournament action, Ryan vs. Ricochet vs. Cross main event
TV REPORTS
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 5/21: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Thursday show, including Roman Reigns' return to Smackdown
JAMES'S WWE NXT "TAKEOVER: UNSTOPPABLE" REPORT 5/20: Owens vs. Zayn for the NXT Title ends in wild fashion with a major debut, plus spectacular NXT Women's Title match, more; Overall Reax
DEHNEL'S LUCHA UNDERGROUND REPORT 5/20: Team Ivellise defends Trios Tag Titles, Prince Puma vs. debuting star, mysteries, more
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 5/18: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live Raw - Payback PPV fall-out, two title matches, packed show includes major Lana-Rusev developments and NXT champ debuting, more
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 5/14: Complete coverage of the Thursday night show, including Seth Rollins vs. Ryback, Kane vs. Roman Reigns
TNA IMPACT NEWS 5/15: Team Young vs. Team Angle main event with mystery partners, Match #1 in Tag Title series, KO Title feud, Bro-Mans explode, more
JAMES'S WWE NXT LIVE REPORT 5/14: In-person perspective on Philly Night 1, including a verbal fight over ... John Cena?
SMACKDOWN NEWS 5/14: Final Payback hype, Reigns holds title belt to close the show, Lana "apologizes," full Match Results
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 5/13 - Week 161: Owens-Zayn final confrontation before Takeover, Itami & Balor vs. Breeze & Rose main event, Women's champ, more
DEHNEL'S LUCHA UNDERGROUND REPORT 5/13: Hernandez vs. Alberto El Patron #1 contender match, Jack Evans debuts, Fight for The Medallion, more
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 5/11: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live Raw - final Payback PPV hype, D-Bryan announces future, Triple H returns, more developments
METZGER'S ROH TV REPORT 5/10: Chris Sabin vs. Kyle O'Reilly, mega-six-man tag main event with Briscoes & Alberto
OPINION & ANALYSIS
SD POLLS 5/21: Vote 0-10 & select Best Match on Smackdown
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL: Who will be the star of NXT tonight?
CHAMBER PPV POLL: Which team would you like to be stuck in a Chamber pod with?
RADICAN'S "JCW's Back B--ch!" DVD Review 1/23: Mercer-Gowen, Jacobs-Kong, Tony-Cabana main event
RAW POLLS 5/18: Vote 0-10 & Select Best Match on Raw
WWE PPV REAX #2: Poll Results on Payback's Best Match, plus second batch of feedback, including live perspective
WWE PPV REAX #1: First batch of feedback on Payback, including hot crowd enhancing the show, who was elevated?, more
MCNEILL'S PPV BLOG 5/17: Live Blog for WWE Payback 2015 - ongoing thoughts & observations
WWE PPV POLLS 5/17: Vote on Payback 0-10, select Best Match
Friction: McNEILL Previews WWE Payback 2015 (with a Wrestling History Lesson)
RADICAN'S ROH/NJPW "GLOBAL WARS 2015" iPPV REPORT 5/15: Bullet Club vs. ROH All-Stars main event, Okada vs. Alexander, more!
SD POLLS 5/14: Vote 0-10 & select Best Match on Smackdown
THE SPECIALISTS
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Action Figure Spotlight - The Edge/Lita/Hardy love triangle 10 years ago; Update on New Card Sales
TUCKER'S LIVE INSTANT REACTION: Payback turns into an enjoyable stand-alone show, but will it stand the test of time?
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Big Year for Wrestling Trading Cards - Topps & Panini to release new cards, including NXT set
5/11 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Cena vs. Neville, Elimination Chamber Announcement, Axel & Sandow, Rollins vs. Orton
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Bellas Dominate List of Top-Selling Divas Figures
5/7 WWE Smackdown Hits & Misses: Sheamus & Barrett vs. Ziggler & Neville, New Day vs. Kidd, Cesaro & Ryback, Rusev, Contract Signing
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Sami Zayn - how will Zayn's Raw TV debut affect sales of Action Figures, Autographs, and more?
HITS & MISSES - 5/4 WWE Raw: Rollins vs. Ambrose, Cena-Zayn, Lana, Orton-Reigns
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Which Trading Cards are Creating Buzz Among Collectors?
COLLECTIBLES COMMENTARY: Denver was a Verne Gagne Town
TUCKER LIVE AT EXTREME RULES: Instant Reaction to an inoffensive, yet somewhat ineffective Sunday night WWE PPV
HITS & MISSES - 4/13 WWE Raw: Cena vs. Barrett, Kane's Storyline, Reigns - Big Show, Extrem Rules Stipulations
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
RAW RETRO - Batista "quits" from a wheelchair 5 yrs. ago, plus Hart named Raw GM, Cole vows to sue Bryan post-NXT attack, Cena vs. Edge vs. Jericho main event, more
WWE PPV FLASHBACK: Batista's back-breaking "I Quit" match vs. Cena 5 yrs. ago today, plus more injuries on undercard
TNA SLAMMIVERSARY 2014: Full Report from last year's PPV airing Friday night in place of Impact on Destination America
FLASHBACK: Samoa Joe vs. Kevin Owens/Steen 10 yrs. ago in PWG
WCW PPV FLASHBACK: Hogan & Savage vs. Flair & Vader 20 yrs. ago today, plus WCW Hall of Fame inductees, IWGP Title match, more
PWG FLASHBACK: Count the number of current WWE & TNA stars on PWG shows held 8 & 9 yrs. ago today
RADICAN'S "JCW's Back B--ch!" DVD Review 1/23: Mercer-Gowen, Jacobs-Kong, Tony-Cabana main event
PPV FLASHBACK: Capital Combat 25 yrs. ago - Flair vs. Luger in the cage, Undertaker when he was Mean Mark, Road Warriors's send-off, and ... Robocop helps Sting
RAW RETRO - Bret Hart captures U.S. Title 5 yrs. ago on Raw, plus Batista tries to force Cena to say I Quit, astronaut guest-stars, more
ECW FLASHBACK: Final Hardcore Heaven 15 yrs. ago today - Credible vs. Storm for ECW Title, Rhino vs. Sandman, RVD vs. Lynn, more
PWG FLASHBACK - Styles vs. Daniels goes 60 minutes for the PWG Title & TNA X Division Title 10 yrs. ago today, plus Steen, Generico, Guerrilla Warfare, more
RADICAN'S ROH "A Lethal Dose" review - Lethal discusses interaction with Savage & Flair, return to ROH, heel turn with Martini, more
REFERENCE
TITLES & CHAMPS: Ongoing list of 2015 Titleholders
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in for Thursday's show
LUCHA NEWS: Updated Lucha Underground TV viewership, plus median age, how Lucha compares to Impact, more
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Raw rebounds to highest rating since post-WM31
TNA NEWS: Impact TV viewership - Impact ends recent downturn
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - how the last two weeks have fared
OBIT: California writer/producer Joe Franciosi dies suddenly
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Raw up from last week's 2.55 rating, but still in year-low territory
TNA NEWS: Impact TV viewership - semi-live episode hits two-month low
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Raw falls from last week's year-low
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings - Thursday's show falls hard post-Extreme Rules
TNA NEWS: Impact TV viewership for Friday's episode
PWTorch Free Podcast
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (5/22) available on-demand - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Jim Ross talks live w/Wade Keller on Thursday's Livecast - now available on-demand
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (5/20) available on-demand - McNeill's All-Star Panel w/FAIRPLAY & Scott Fishman
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (5/19) available on-demand - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (5/18) available on-demand - Raw post-game show w/James Caldwell & live callers
LIVECAST AUDIO: Special PWTorch Livecast (5/17) Payback post-game show now available on-demand - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (5/15) available on-demand - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant take live calls
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (5/14) available on-demand - Wade Keller interviews former WWE writer John Piermarini
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (5/13) available on-demand - Pat McNeill's All-Star Panel w/Bill Behrens
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (5/12) available on-demand - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (5/11) available on-demand - James Caldwell's Raw Post-Game Show w/live callers
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (5/8) available on-demand - Bruce Mitchell & Brad Stutts of Mid-Atlantic Championship Wrestling
VIP Exclusive Features
VIP - 05/24 - Wade Keller Hotline - NXT Takeover: Full rundown and analysis of standout NXT Women’s Title match, debut of Samoa Joe, Itami injury angle, Rhino vs. Corbin, Charlotte, Stephanie, more (31 min.)
VIP - 05/24 Bruce Mitchell Audio Show w/Wade Keller: Samoa Joe’s WWE contract and what it means for his future in WWE and elsewhere, which women today would fit in well in past eras, what’s the story on Tommy “Wildfire” Rich (54 min.)
VIP - 05/24 McNeill & Valley's "Wayback Playback" Audio Show (ep. #36): Into the WWF Time Machine for Hour #3 of King of the Ring '93 - The Finals, IC Title, more! (65 min.)
VIP - 05/24 Audio Flashback - WWE Judgment Day PPV Rapid-Fire Analysis with Keller & Powell: Analysis of Cena-JBL I Quit match, Rey vs. Eddie, Booker vs. Angle, Carlito vs. Big Show, MNM vs. Holly & Haas (12 min.)
VIP - 05/23 Moonlighting with Greg Parks: Discussing and analyzing the latest episodes of WWE Smackdown, Lucha Underground, and NXT Takeover: Unstoppable (37 min.)
VIP - 05/23 Radican's Wrestling Community Audio (w/Metzger & Leahy) - Samoa Joe NXT debut, ROH iPPV review, NXT live in Albany, Progress Wrestling, more! (50 min.)
VIP - 05/23 - Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Smackdown ratings, Lucha Underground viewership, Rousey, Young Bucks, Flair, Puder, Extreme Rules PPV buys, Manchester WWE results, Morrison movie, more (26 min.)
VIP - 05/23 Audio Flashback - Real Deal w/Pat McNeill (05-21-2005): Kevin Steen/Owens and El Generico/Sami Zayn in Indy Line-up of Week, Bryan’s departure from ROH, TV timeslot shuffling, Hot Five Stories (28 min.)
VIP - 05/22 PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow: Mitchell & Bryant discuss Kevin Owens’s bright future, TNA’s future on Destination America, the improvement in Cena’s promos, Finn Balor’s ring entrance, NXT Takeover, more (82 min.)
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1405 (PDF & TEXT): Keller’s WWE Payback, Raw, and Smackdown reports, Torch Staff PPV Roundtable Reviews, Keller’s End Notes on Triple H’s NXT Conference Call, ROH iPPV reports, Parks column (24 pages)
VIP - 05/22 - Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Is John Cena really actually putting new guys over lately? Would TNA going out of business really be bad for industry? What is missing from Kidd & Cesaro’s act? (35 min.)
VIP - 05/22 Audio Flashback - Bruce Mitchell Audio Show (05-20-2005): WWE Draft Lottery, Matt Hardy's potential in TNA, Styles re-signing with TNA, Mcmahon's speech to Randy Orton and the real message it was sending, ECW (90 min.)