PWTORCH.COM

Select List of Articles by Category Type

SEARCH PWTORCH



CONTACT US

 JUMP TO VIP SITE

VIP SIGN-UP INFO

JUMP TO MMATORCH

UGO AFFILIATE

A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999


PWTorch is customized for your mobile phone such as your Blackberry. Just enter www.pwtorch.com on your phone's browser and choose the "Mobile" option. Samsung Omnia II users, download our free Widget. Apple iPhone users, download our free PWTorch App (search "pwtorch")



 

CALDWELL'S TAKE

CALDWELL: The real story on Eugene (Nick Dinsmore) is not questionable TV content, but Dinsmore himself

Feb 12, 2010 - 11:56:42 AM


Staff08Caldwell_120c_169.jpg
By James Caldwell, Torch assistant editor

Much has been made lately about the "Eugene" mentally-challenged character that was introduced on WWE TV in April 2004.

Videos have circulated to Connecticut media members interested in former WWE CEO Linda McMahon's Senate race showing classic, fun-for-all-ages WWE video clips such as Eugene being destroyed by Triple H in a steel cage.

Hartford Courant's Rick Green even went to McMahon's Senate campaign HQ looking for answers from McMahon herself.

"There was never any intent of WWE to make fun of anyone who is developmentally challenged in any way," McMahon said. "It was to show how you can rise above your circumstances. He always had this quality of believing he could be anything he wanted to be. It's a soap opera. It's all a matter of taste."

McMahon added: I don't want you to mischaracterize what my judgment is. Eugene was an example of the different kinds of issues that can be addressed in life. Here was a fellow who really believed who he was and there were no obstacles to him. It portrayed an element in life that gave hope and inspiration to others."

Ah, yes, the "subjective analysis" of WWE programming argument. It's a disarming argument that calms the issue and doesn't grab headlines or inspire voters to sway one or the other.

What might sway voters or at least expose a scar WWE has tried to cover is the real story about the real person who played the Eugene character.

Eugene was played by Nick Dinsmore, who was a three-strikes-and-you're-out victim of the Wellness Policy. Dinsmore dealt with prescription painkiller addiction while with WWE.

"I always rationalized it as my back hurts, my knee hurts, I can't go out there and perform in pain, so I have to do something about it," Dinsmore said in a February 2009 interview. Read the story.)

Even more troubling was WWE sending Dinsmore on an international tour in late 2005 just days after the death of his close friend, Eddie Guerrero, whose death rushed along the implementation of the current Wellness Policy.

Torch columnist Bruce Mitchell wrote in December 2005 about Dinsmore's pain pill addiction escalating at the time and WWE using him as an example weeks after Guerrero's death.

Nick Dinsmore, who considered Eddie Guerrero a close friend and mentor ever since he recommended him for a spot on the main roster, was not allowed to go to the funeral. Instead, he was forced to make the immediate, arduous trip to England, where he was expected to act out his on camera mentally impaired always happy Eugene character anytime he was seen in public. He made it less than a week, then passed out in a hotel lobby from an overdose of Soma pain pills. He was immediately suspended and sent to rehab. Because of PR considerations in the wake of Guerrero's death, Dinsmore's condition and its consequences were immediately made public in a way that had never happened before.

The real stories in Linda McMahon's Connecticut Senate race are not on the surface with TV content, characters, and storylines. Sure, they're part of the dialogue that has to be included because WWE's TV programming reaches impressionable children who still point to their crotches and yell "suck it!" on school buses (just ask my wife, who teaches Pre-K), but the real stories are below the surface.

Dinsmore's story is not the "Eugene" character, but the prescription pain pills, following "the show must go on" mentality following yet another wrestler death that is still prevalent in today's wrestling industry, and pushing his body when it never should have been pushed.

McMahon has yet to account for the real story on a former WWE star after easily talking down the surface-level story.


Send feedback on this article to pwtorch@gmail.com and we'll regularly publish reader feedback in the "Torch Feedback" category on the Main Listing.

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA...
VISIT OUR AFFILIATE - PROWRESTLING.NET

For UFC & MMA NEWS & BLOGS:
VISIT OUR SISTER SITE - MMATORCH.COM

Upgrade to PWTorch VIP:

 DETAILS & SIGN-UP INFO (VIP Newsletter, Audio, Archives, No Ads on Website, VIP Email Reports, VIP Forum, more.)

More Recent CALDWELL'S TAKE Articles
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.

STAFF PICKS - TOP TEN RECENT ARTICLES
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1377 (PDF & TEXT): Orton-Cena takes on new meaning with major added stip, Austin Torch Talk on what's missing from Orton, Mitchell on Pro Wrestling's New Era, Pg. 2 Radar preview of Lucha Underground
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV SPOILERS 10/24 - results & updates for final episode leading into HIAC PPV
WWE NEWS: HIAC PPV Update - Pre-Show line-up & final card
VIP - 10/17 AD-FREE PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow w/Rob Van Dam: Fascinating insights, memories, opinions spanning his entire career in ECW, WCW, WWE, plus opinion on Punk, Undertaker, Rollins, Ambrose, PPV payoffs (106 min.)
TV REPORTS & RESULTS: Main Event, Caldwell's Raw Report, Smackdown, Impact, NXT, ROH TV, more



PWTORCH FREE AUDIO SHOWS
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/24) now available - Wade Keller talks live w/Sean Waltman
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (10/23) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (10/22) now available - McNeill w/wrestling author Paul O'Brien
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (10/21) now available - Wade Keller takes live calls
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (10/20) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/17) now available - RVD Interview w/Wade Keller

PWTORCH INSTANT POLL
LIVECAST POLL: Who do you think will be WWE champion at the end of the year?
 
pollcode.com free polls
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL: Which match at Hell in a Cell are you looking forward to most?
 
pollcode.com free polls


LIVECAST POLL: Which HIAC match should go on last at the PPV?
 
pollcode.com free polls
RAW POLL 10/20: If you watched Raw, the show was...
 
pollcode.com free polls


HIAC PPV POLL 10/20: What's your view on WWE's Hell in a Cell PPV?
 
pollcode.com free polls
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

UPCOMING MAJOR EVENTS

SELECT LIST OF ARTICLES BY CATEGORY

ARTICLES GROUPED BY CATEGORY
NEWS REPORTS
PWG NEWS: Top matches announced for PWG's year-end show, including all titles on the line
FRIDAY EVENTS: Hardy in Vegas for FSW, DDP & Jake & Jonny at Epic Con, Booker T goes Big Time, NXT, more
WWE NEWS: The Case of Dolph Ziggler - IC champ recognizes his position, would he side with or oppose Authority?, more
NEWSWIRE: Zeus calls out John Cena, "Booker" Matt Hardy?, new Jericho DVD, Hogan vs. Gawker legal update, WWE delivering a Christmas present to investors, more
WWE NEWS: Non-Spoiler matches for Friday's Smackdown episode, plus SPOILER results link
LASHLEY NEWS: TNA World champ returning to Bellator MMA Friday night on Spike TV
WWE NEWS: NXT SPOILERS - full results from Thursday's TV taping, including line-up for the next NXT special, plus Seth Rollins makes post-taping appearance, more
WWE NETWORK: Friday, October 24 Schedule
WWE NEWS: NXT SPOILERS - early notes from tonight's TV taping at Full Sail University
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in for Wednesday's show
ROSS NEWS: Jim Ross addresses rumor of calling New Japan's Tokyo Dome PPV on January 4
WWE NEWS: Brock Lesnar spotted out in public ... smiling
PPV REPORTS
PPV RESULTS - 10/13 New Japan in Tokyo, Japan: Styles drops IWGP World Hvt. Title to Tanahashi, more title changes, former WWE star returns to New Japan, more
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - Night of Champions: Best/Worst Match, Surprise/Letdown, Updated 2014 PPV Rankings, and a message to WWE on making PPV buyers feel like morons
ROH "ALL-STAR EXTRAVAGANZA" ROUNDTABLE: Radican, Metzger, Leahy rate & review ROH's most-recent show
MCNEILL'S PPV BLOG 9/21: Live Blog for Night of Champions - ongoing thoughts & observations
CALDWELL'S WWE NOC PPV REPORT 9/21: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live PPV - Lesnar vs. Cena
CALDWELL'S WWE NOC PPV REPORT 9/21 (Pre-Show): Christian's Peep Show with Jericho, Roman Reigns injury update
CALDWELL'S NEW JAPAN PPV RESULTS 9/21: Complete live coverage of "Destruction in Kobe" - Nakamura regains IC Title, Tanahashi vs. Shibata, A.J. Styles, new Jr. Hvt. champion, more
RADICAN'S EVOLVE 35 iPPV REPORT: Complete coverage of outstanding Show of the Year candidate
RADICAN'S IPPV REPORT - EVOLVE 34 in New York: Drew Galloway defends Evolve Title, DGUSA Tag Title match, more
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - WWE Summerslam: Best/Worst Match, Direction Since SSlam, Updated 2014 PPV Rankings
METZGER'S ROH IPPV REPORT 9/6: Elgin vs. Briscoe ROH Title match, Tag Title main event, changes, more
PPV RESULTS - 9/5 "Maskedmania" from Philadelphia, Pa.: Sabu, Homicide, Cross, Lucha stars featured
TV REPORTS
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 10/23: Swagger vs. Bo Dallas main event, plus Kofi vs. Kidd
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 10/23: Neville defends NXT Title against Titus O'Neil, Tyler Breeze, Ascension, more; Overall Reax
TNA IMPACT RESULTS 10/22: TNA Title match contract signing, Tag Tournament begins, hardcore match, more
DEHNEL'S WWE MAIN EVENT RESULTS 10/21: Usos and Goldust hype Tag Title match ... with a game show, Rollins vs. Swagger main event, Big E. is not a Bo-Liever, more
WWE RAW POST-GAME SHOW REPORT 10/20: Hulk Hogan's post-Raw interview, plus Hogan & Cena Posedown
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 10/20: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Raw vs. NFL Week 7 - final PPV hype, Cena & Ambrose vs. The Authority, Heyman returns, military angle, more
METZGER'S ROH TV REPORT 10/19: Former ROH champ Adam Cole main event, Decade drama, more
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 10/17: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Friday show, including The Usos & Sheamus vs. The Rhodes Brothers & The Miz
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 10/16: Bo Dallas vs. Zack Ryder, Kofi steps up vs. Cesaro, Justin Roberts, more
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 10/16 - Week 122: Sami Zayn vs. Tyson Kidd main event, Women's champ Charlotte; Overall Reax
TNA IMPACT RESULTS 10/15: New #1 contender to the TNA Title, post-BFG developments, Brodus Clay debuts, heels & faces shown sitting together in a banquet room, more
DEHNEL'S WWE MAIN EVENT REPORT 10/14: Rusev vs. Big E., Miz TV with Sheamus, Cesaro vs. Justin Gabriel, Truth vs. Tyson Kidd
OPINION & ANALYSIS
QOTD REAX #3: More feedback on Network viewing habits, including a tape collector's perspective
QOTD REAX #2: More reader feedback on WWE Network viewing habits, including obligation to watch PPVs
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 10/23: Could Goldust be elevated to a singles main event run before retiring? Is there a bright side to Lesnar's title schedule? Could wrestling end up off national cable some day? What's best non-WM PPV?
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STARS 10/23: When wrestlers do the DDT mid-match today is that disrespectful to Jake Roberts? Isn't having less frequent WWE Title defenses making title matches a bigger deal? Who should Stone Cold face? 2020's top stars?
QOTD REAX #1: Readers share WWE Network experience - what are they watching?, how often?, more
THE STATE OF TNA: Special Report on TNA's current standing, future prospects, and the "big play"
QUESTION OF THE DAY: How often do you watch WWE Network?
VOTE: Who will be WWE World champion at year-end?
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STARS 10/22: Does WWE touting RKO imitations contradict their Don't Try This At Home message? Who should be pushed better? Has Zeb always been such a good talker? Could MITB be cashed in mid-match?
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 10/22: Has Vince McMahon had other altercations with wrestlers? Why does The Rock seem more comfortable now than during his Cena feud? Did Low Ki really get fired by WWE? Should Reigns return as a heel?
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 10/22: Why does The Rock seem more comfortable now than during his Cena feud? Did Low Ki really get fired by WWE? Should Reigns return as a heel? Has Vince McMahon had other altercations with wrestlers?
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLLS: Which WWE PPV match are you most looking forward to?, plus which HIAC match should go on last?
THE SPECIALISTS
VALLEY'S TAKE: Wrestling Fans Are Frustrated, But Why?, Plus Random Thoughts on RKO Vines, Triple H, more
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest Evaluation of WWE prospects, plus play along with the Drake Younger hashtag
10/20 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Miz & Mizdow, Orton - Cena - Heyman,, Mick Foley, Rusev - Big Show, Ambrose and a Mannequin
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Batista’s Star-Making Role Has Collectors Chasing His "Guardians" Cards
TUCKER'S RAW INSTANT REACTION: "This Hell in a Cell sure is dangerous ... now time for a joke"
VALLEY'S TAKE: Who are these guys? Fans aren't given enough information to be fully emotionally invested in today's WWE stars, plus Random Thoughts
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest NXT Rankings & Evaluation of WWE's top prospects
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: 20 Years Later - Sabu's Loyal Following of Trading Card Collectors
HITS & MISSES - 10/13 WWE Raw: Orton vs. Ziggler, Rollins vs. Swagger, Less Crap, Cena vs. Ambrose
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest Rankings & Weekly Evaluation of the NXT TV show
RAW HITS & MISSES 10/6: Ambrose and Cena, Roman Reigns, The Rock, Lots of Crap
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Collectors Paying Big Bucks For New Topps WrestleMania Product
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
WWE NEWS FIVE YEARS AGO - Shane McMahon shocks wrestling industry by resigning from WWE
WCW WEDNESDAY: Nitro episode airing today on WWE Network - Ric Flair vs. Hulk Hogan on live Nitro
10 YRS AGO: Ring of Honor event in Chicago features Punk vs. Samoa Joe one hour draw, plus Delirious, Sydal, Nigel, Jacobs, Shelley, Homicide
WWE RAW 5 YEARS AGO: WWE forces Raw vs. Smackdown feud leading to Bragging Rights, plus Snoop Dogg, Triple H vs. John Cena, Marty Jannetty, more
10 YRS AGO - WWE Live Event - 10/19/2004 in Minneapolis: Undertaker vs. JBL in main event among worst main events ever, Big Show vs. Angle, Carlito vs. Eddie, Taker vs. Heidenreich
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 Climax 23: Day 1" report 8/1/13 - Suzuki-Nagata, Tanahashi-Kojima, Okada-Devitt main event
RADICAN'S "The Kevin Steen Show with Gabe Sapolsky" review - fatherhood, lessons learned after being fired from ROH, launching EVOLVE, Heyman, inside the Steen-Generico-Briscoes feud
RADICAN'S CHIKARA King of Trios 2014: Night 2 report 9/20 - Rey De Voladores mini-tournament begins, Spud, Sanda, Tatsu in action, Flood-Colony main event
20 YRS AGO: Report on WWE house show at Bourne High School headlined by Bulldog vs. Owen, Razor Ramon vs. Backlund, plus Adam Bomb, Volkoff, bundy, Doink, Gunns
10 YRS AGO: Reader Reax to Oct. 14, 2004 edition of Raw with Ric Flair, RVD, Austin, Steiner, RVD, Shawn Michaels, Goldberg, Bishoff
20 YRS AGO: Cactus vs. Sabu headlines NWA event - pioneering hardcore style match with moonsault onto table, plus Al Snow
10 YRS AGO MITCHELL: Mojo Raw Commentary Stream on Hurricane, Jericho, Coach, Bischoff, Molly, Nowinski, RVD
REFERENCE
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in for Wednesday's show
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in for Monday's show - how did the HIAC lead-in episode fare?
WWE NEWS: Total Divas continues Sunday night slide
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in for Friday's show
TITLES & CHAMPS: Ongoing list of 2014 Titleholders
TNA NEWS: Impact TV quarter-hour ratings - details on this week's show sliding to near-low on Wednesday nights
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Monday's show rebounds from year-low, but there is a concerning demo & viewership pattern
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - how did the 15th Anniversary episode fare?
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in - how did the latest Wednesday night episode fare?
WWE NEWS: Raw TV quarter-hour ratings - Rock saves Raw from historical low point, plus which promoted segments did not draw?
WWE NEWS: Full Raw TV Ratings Report - Raw hits Rock Bottom
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - Friday's show makes big leap to end September Swoon
PWTorch Free Podcast
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/24) now available - Wade Keller talks live w/Sean Waltman
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (10/23) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (10/22) now available - McNeill w/wrestling author Paul O'Brien
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (10/21) now available - Wade Keller takes live calls
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (10/20) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/17) now available - RVD Interview w/Wade Keller
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (10/16) now available - Jim Valley guest hosts with special guests
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (10/15) now available - Pat McNeill's Interview Wednesday
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (10/14) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (10/13) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (10/10) now available - Wade Keller interviews Matt McCarthy
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (10/9) now available - Jim Valley & Greg Parks
VIP Exclusive Features
VIP - 10/24 Vintage Audio (14 Yrs. Ago) - Attitude Era Wrestling Radio - Total Chaos Radio with Jim Valley from July 1, 2000 including WCW and WWF politics during Monday Night War, WWF releases, WWF leaving USA Network (58 min.)
VIP - 10/24 Audio Flashback - Wade Keller Hotline (09-27-2004): Andy Rooney on "60 Minutes" says pro wrestling fans shouldn't vote in elections, Diva Search, Taboo Tuesday concept introduced, The Angle Alliance, Billy Gunn gone (23 min.)
VIP - 10/23 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Lesnar surfaces in public, Dana White talks about prospects of Lesnar UFC return, TNA ratings and latest in future, Stephanie on WWE Network, PWI 500 thoughts, big NXT developments (30 min.)
VIP - 10/23 Bruce Mitchell Audio Show w/Wade Keller, pt. 1: WWE Hell in a Cell PPV preview with analysis of build-up and new stips for Orton vs. Cena with Lesnar's name reintroduced, Foley's return, mannequin skit, Show-Rusev angle (87 min.)
VIP - 10/23 PWTorch Livecast: James Caldwell & Greg Parks: HIAC preview & picks, "weird" decision-making on Raw, Midas Touch missing from WWE Network, Impact review, is Jim Ross calling wrestling worth a PPV buy?, more! (90 min.)
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1377 (PDF & TEXT): Orton-Cena takes on new meaning with major added stip, Austin Torch Talk on what's missing from Orton, Mitchell on Pro Wrestling's New Era, Pg. 2 Radar preview of Lucha Underground
VIP - 10/22 East Coast Cast (ep. #213): More silliness for Dean Ambrose, more greatness from Seth Rollins, worst heel & face on WWE roster?, VIP Conversation, more! (190 min.)
VIP - 10/22 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: How to get Cesaro to main event level act, Rusev should be U.S. Champion with Cena chasing him, Renee Young should be on Raw, turn Lawler heel, Ambrose too scripted (28 min.)
VIP - 10/22 PWTorch Livecast: Pat McNeill w/wrestling author Paul O'Brien - "Blood Red Turns Dollar Green" book-writing process, contributions & endorsements from big names in wrestling, more!; VIP - News & Events (90 min.)
VIP - 10/22 Audio Flashback - Mitchell & McNeill & Keller Roundtable (09-26-2004): Angle overrates himself, Heidenreich turns to poetry, State of TNA Address, SD anniversary with Hogan and Austin, was the Raw Divas Search worth it (96 min.)
VIP - 10/21 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Raw and Smackdown ratings analysis, Total Divas slides, reaction to Stephanie's Yahoo Sports interview, WWE Domestic Violence policy, Hogan's post-Raw comments, Smackdown spoilers (23 min.)
VIP - 10/21 PWTorch Livecast: Wade Keller takes live calls on topics including Monday's Raw, whether KENTA/Itami will succeed on the main roster, WWE Network biz, New Japan compared to WWE, and much more! (83 min.)