PWTORCH.COM

Select List of Articles by Category Type

SEARCH PWTORCH



CONTACT US

 JUMP TO VIP SITE

VIP SIGN-UP INFO

JUMP TO MMATORCH

UGO AFFILIATE

A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999


PWTorch is customized for your mobile phone such as your Blackberry. Just enter www.pwtorch.com on your phone's browser and choose the "Mobile" option. Samsung Omnia II users, download our free Widget. Apple iPhone users, download our free PWTorch App (search "pwtorch")



 

CALDWELL'S TAKE

CALDWELL: The real story on Eugene (Nick Dinsmore) is not questionable TV content, but Dinsmore himself

Feb 12, 2010 - 11:56:42 AM


Staff08Caldwell_120c_169.jpg
By James Caldwell, Torch assistant editor

Much has been made lately about the "Eugene" mentally-challenged character that was introduced on WWE TV in April 2004.

Videos have circulated to Connecticut media members interested in former WWE CEO Linda McMahon's Senate race showing classic, fun-for-all-ages WWE video clips such as Eugene being destroyed by Triple H in a steel cage.

Hartford Courant's Rick Green even went to McMahon's Senate campaign HQ looking for answers from McMahon herself.

"There was never any intent of WWE to make fun of anyone who is developmentally challenged in any way," McMahon said. "It was to show how you can rise above your circumstances. He always had this quality of believing he could be anything he wanted to be. It's a soap opera. It's all a matter of taste."

McMahon added: I don't want you to mischaracterize what my judgment is. Eugene was an example of the different kinds of issues that can be addressed in life. Here was a fellow who really believed who he was and there were no obstacles to him. It portrayed an element in life that gave hope and inspiration to others."

Ah, yes, the "subjective analysis" of WWE programming argument. It's a disarming argument that calms the issue and doesn't grab headlines or inspire voters to sway one or the other.

What might sway voters or at least expose a scar WWE has tried to cover is the real story about the real person who played the Eugene character.

Eugene was played by Nick Dinsmore, who was a three-strikes-and-you're-out victim of the Wellness Policy. Dinsmore dealt with prescription painkiller addiction while with WWE.

"I always rationalized it as my back hurts, my knee hurts, I can't go out there and perform in pain, so I have to do something about it," Dinsmore said in a February 2009 interview. Read the story.)

Even more troubling was WWE sending Dinsmore on an international tour in late 2005 just days after the death of his close friend, Eddie Guerrero, whose death rushed along the implementation of the current Wellness Policy.

Torch columnist Bruce Mitchell wrote in December 2005 about Dinsmore's pain pill addiction escalating at the time and WWE using him as an example weeks after Guerrero's death.

Nick Dinsmore, who considered Eddie Guerrero a close friend and mentor ever since he recommended him for a spot on the main roster, was not allowed to go to the funeral. Instead, he was forced to make the immediate, arduous trip to England, where he was expected to act out his on camera mentally impaired always happy Eugene character anytime he was seen in public. He made it less than a week, then passed out in a hotel lobby from an overdose of Soma pain pills. He was immediately suspended and sent to rehab. Because of PR considerations in the wake of Guerrero's death, Dinsmore's condition and its consequences were immediately made public in a way that had never happened before.

The real stories in Linda McMahon's Connecticut Senate race are not on the surface with TV content, characters, and storylines. Sure, they're part of the dialogue that has to be included because WWE's TV programming reaches impressionable children who still point to their crotches and yell "suck it!" on school buses (just ask my wife, who teaches Pre-K), but the real stories are below the surface.

Dinsmore's story is not the "Eugene" character, but the prescription pain pills, following "the show must go on" mentality following yet another wrestler death that is still prevalent in today's wrestling industry, and pushing his body when it never should have been pushed.

McMahon has yet to account for the real story on a former WWE star after easily talking down the surface-level story.


Send feedback on this article to pwtorch@gmail.com and we'll regularly publish reader feedback in the "Torch Feedback" category on the Main Listing.

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA...
VISIT OUR AFFILIATE - PROWRESTLING.NET

For UFC & MMA NEWS & BLOGS:
VISIT OUR SISTER SITE - MMATORCH.COM

Upgrade to PWTorch VIP:

 DETAILS & SIGN-UP INFO (VIP Newsletter, Audio, Archives, No Ads on Website, VIP Email Reports, VIP Forum, more.)

More Recent CALDWELL'S TAKE Articles
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.

STAFF PICKS - TOP TEN RECENT ARTICLES
WWE BIZ NEWS: WWE reports Q2-2014 results, releases Network sub count, announces big TV/Network deal, more
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1365 (PDF & TEXT): Keller's Cover Story and End Notes on TNA-Spike situation, Keller's Pg. 2 Radar on Ventura Verdict and Network Royalties, Mitchell's TNA Memorial Quiz, Parks on Booker T's iPPV
LATEST TV REPORTS: Caldwell's In-Person Raw Report, Parks's Raw TV & SD Reports, ROH TV, Impact, NXT, more
LATEST TNA NEWS: Impact reportedly not renewed for Fall Season, what are both parties saying?, plus Impact TV ratings
LIVECAST AUDIO: Booker T interview w/Wade Keller on Friday's PWTorch Livecast



PWTORCH FREE AUDIO SHOWS
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/31) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/30) now available - McNeill's All-Star Panel w/Petey Williams & Billy Reil
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (7/29) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (7/28) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/24) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/23) now available - Ezekiel Jackson Interview w/McNeill

PWTORCH INSTANT POLL
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL 7/30: Will TNA Wrestling be in business six months from now?
  
pollcode.com free polls 
RAW POLL 7/28: If you watched Raw, Monday's show was...
  
pollcode.com free polls 


RAW POLL 7/28: How do you feel about Summerslam right now?
  
pollcode.com free polls 
SMACKDOWN POLL 7/25: If you watched Friday's Smackdown, the show was...
  
pollcode.com free polls 
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

UPCOMING MAJOR EVENTS

SELECT LIST OF ARTICLES BY CATEGORY

ARTICLES GROUPED BY CATEGORY
NEWS REPORTS
WWE NEWS: Non-Spoiler Smackdown match listing for Friday
IMPACT NEWS: TNA Title match result, Hardys reunite to challenge for Tag Titles, X Title finalists, more
WWE Q2 RESULTS: How the financial community reacted to WWE's latest earnings report & what it says about varying opinions of WWE's financial state
TNA NEWS: X Division wrestler re-signs, MMA fighter says he's "never going back" to TNA (w/Video)
SHOW RESULTS - 7/31 BCW at the State Fair: Steve Corino vs. Greg Valentine headlines Brew City show
WWE CONFERENCE CALL: The latest on Network biz model changes, pricing plans, SSlam push, int'l reach, more
WWE CONFERENCE CALL: Non-Network highlights from McMahon & Barrios - what led to WWE cutting staff?, domestic attendance, Studios spending, more TV deals
WWE Q2 RESULTS: Revenue & Profit/Loss Break Down for all business segments - TV, PPV, Network, Home Video, more
WWE NEWS: Latest WWE Network subscriber count released, plus WWE announces big Network/TV deal in Canada
WWE Q2 RESULTS: PPV Business Break Down - WM30, MITB vs. Payback in June, other factors in Network Era
WWE Q2 RESULTS: WWE issues revised 2014 Business Outlook, including new Network data on break-even point
WWE Q2 RESULTS: WWE reports Second Quarter financial results - Net Loss, Revenue increase, office staff cuts
PPV REPORTS
RADICAN'S NJPW G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 6 REPORT 7/31 - Shibata-Kojima, Tanahashi-Ishii, Styles-Tenzan
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 5 REPORT 7/28 - excellent show including Shibata-Benjamin, Nakamura-Honma standout matches, Naito-Okada MOTYC
PARKS'S REALITY OF WRESTLING "SUMMER OF CHAMPIONS" iPPV REVIEW - ROW Title Steel Cage Match, appearances by Teddy Long, DDP, Brother Devon, others
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 4 REPORT" 7/26 - show of the year contender w/ Styles-Naito, Shibata-Tanahashi, Nakamura-Nagata standout matches
RADICAN'S NJPW G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 3 REPORT 7/25 - Bullet Club in action, Tanahasi-Kojima, Okada-Makabe standout matches
MCNEILL's Deadblog of WWE Battlegeound: Budget Cuts, Follow That, She's Taken, The Tourist, The Champ, more
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 2" REPORT 7/23 - Kojima-Ishii slugfest, Okada, Styles, Tanahashi-Gallows main event
RADICAN'S NJPW REVIEW SERIES: "G1 Climax 24: Night 1" 7/21 - Goto-Makabe steal the show, Styles-Okada, Shibata-Nakamura
CALDWELL'S NJPW G1 CLIMAX RESULTS 7/21 (Night 1): Complete coverage of A.J. Styles vs. Okada main event, Tanahashi, Nakamura, Shelton Benjamin, Bullet Club, more
CALDWELL'S WWE BATTLEGROUND PPV REPORT 7/20: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live PPV - Cena defends WWE Title, IC Title battle royal, Usos vs. Wyatts Tag Title match, more
CALDWELL'S WWE BATTLEGROUND PPV REPORT 7/20 (Pre-Show): Fandango vs. Rose, Cameron vs. Naomi, more
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - WWE MITB 2014: Best/Worst Match, Surprise/Finish, Updated 2014 PPV Rankings
TV REPORTS
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 7/31: Slater Gator vs. Ryder & Cara, Del Rio cut open, more
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 7/31 - Week 109: Kidd vs. Rose main event, #1 contender tournament begins, Overall Reax
CALDWELL'S TNA IMPACT RESULTS 7/31: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of "Destination X" Impact special
CALDWELL'S WWE MAIN EVENT RESULTS 7/29: Ambrose vs. Del Rio main event, Tag Champs, more
PARKS'S WWE RAW REPORT 7/28: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of the continuing road to Summerslam, follow-up on the Stephanie McMahon arrest angle
CALDWELL'S IN-PERSON WWE RAW RESULTS 7/28: Live coverage of Cena's return, "arrest" fall-out, more
METZGER'S ROH TV RESULTS 7/26: Daniels & Kazarian become #1 contenders, Moose, ROH Tag Champs, more
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/25: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Friday show, including Dean Ambrose vs. Cesaro in a no-disqualification match, Roman Reigns vs. Alberto Del Rio
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 7/24: Rose vs. Slater, Swoggle joins the Exotic Express, Del Rio vs. Truth, more
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 7/24 - Week 108: Charlotte defends NXT Women's Title, Rusev faces NXT Champ; Overall Reax
CALDWELL'S TNA IMPACT RESULTS 7/24: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Hardys, Team 3D, more from New York
CALDWELL'S WWE MAIN EVENT RESULTS 7/22: Rusev vs. Swagger PPV re-match, Kofi & Big E. reset, tag champ loses, more
OPINION & ANALYSIS
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 7/31: What is the name of this era and the next era of pro wrestling? Should Styles have to go to WWE Developmental if he signs? Should MITB match executions change? Is Darren Young being punished for coming out as gay?
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 7/31: What is the name of this era and the next era of pro wrestling? Should Styles have to go to WWE Developmental if he signs? Is Darren Young being punished for coming out as gay? Should MITB match executions change?
RADICAN'S NJPW G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 6 REPORT 7/31 - Shibata-Kojima, Tanahashi-Ishii, Styles-Tenzan
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL 7/31: Is Lesnar losing at WM31 too soon? Whom should Angle wrestle if he returns to WWE? Should A.J. Lee do GTS in Chicago? What do you think of Lana?
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL 7/31: Whom should Angle wrestle if he returns to WWE? Should A.J. Lee do GTS in Chicago? What do you think of Lana? Is Lesnar losing at WM31 too soon?
ASK THE SPECIALISTS: Roundtable #50 - How far can Prince Devitt go in WWE?
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 7/30: Could Bryan return and ascend to be co-top-face with Reigns next year? Could Poffo be to blame for Sandow’s character change? Will fans cheer Lesnar against Cena? Why don’t heel teams cheat in corner anymore?
ASK PWTORCH STAFF for 7/30: Could Poffo be to blame for Sandow’s character change? Will fans cheer Lesnar against Cena? Could Bryan return and ascend to be co-top-face with Reigns next year? Why don’t heel teams cheat in corner anymore?
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL 7/30: Could WWE be getting more out of Hulk Hogan? What is Junkyard Dog’s legacy? Does WWE set up wrestlers to fail? Could Ambrose-Rollins feud go to WM31? Is David Otunga still around?
ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL 7/30: Is David Otunga still around? Could WWE be getting more out of Hulk Hogan? What is Junkyard Dog’s legacy? Does WWE set up wrestlers to fail? Could Ambrose-Rollins feud go to WM31?
MCNEILL POLL: Will TNA still be in business by year-end?
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 5 REPORT 7/28 - excellent show including Shibata-Benjamin, Nakamura-Honma standout matches, Naito-Okada MOTYC
THE SPECIALISTS
TUCKER ON IMPACT 7/31: Instant Reaction to Destination X Impact special
7/28 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Cena - Heyman, Cena vs. Cesaro, Jericho vs. Rollins, Stephanie - Brie Bella
VALENTINO'S MAGIC, MEMORIES & MANIA: Live at Comic Con - notes on Hogan, Anderson, wrestler costumes, more
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Looking Back to the First TNA Trading Cards from 10 Years Ago
TUCKER'S INSTANT REACTION - Raw 7/28: What's heating up & cooling down heading into Summerslam?
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Latest Network Era Rankings & Evaluation of the NXT Roster
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: The Growing Legacy of Gary Hart's book, plus Court Bauer talks what makes the book so valuable
7/21 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Reigns vs. Orton & Kane, Stephanie McMahon, The Highlight Reel, Ziggler vs. Miz, Ambrose vs. Cesaro
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: Collectors Are Buying Into Stephanie McMahon’s Trading Cards
TUCKER LIVE AT RAW: Instant Reaction & DVR Guide to disjointed post-Battleground episode
TUCKER LIVE AT BATTLEGROUND: Instant Reaction to "Sunday Night Raw" setting up Summerslam
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: The Wrestling Book Priced At $1,200
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
RADICAN'S NJPW G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 6 REPORT 7/31 - Shibata-Kojima, Tanahashi-Ishii, Styles-Tenzan
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 5 REPORT 7/28 - excellent show including Shibata-Benjamin, Nakamura-Honma standout matches, Naito-Okada MOTYC
RADICAN'S OMEGA CHAMPIONSHIP WRESTLING "CHAOS IN CAMERON" REVIEW 4/26 - Trevor Lee impresses against Adam Page, Hardy Boyz-Briscoes dream match main event
RADICAN'S NJPW "G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 4 REPORT" 7/26 - show of the year contender w/ Styles-Naito, Shibata-Tanahashi, Nakamura-Nagata standout matches
RADICAN'S NJPW G1 CLIMAX 24: NIGHT 3 REPORT 7/25 - Bullet Club in action, Tanahasi-Kojima, Okada-Makabe standout matches
RADICAN'S REVIEW SERIES: "The Kevin Steen Show with Rich Swann" - growing up with difficult circumstances, musical talent, stories from Japan, DGUSA/EVOLVE, CZW, PWG
RADICAN'S ROH REVIEW SERIES: "Aftershock" 7/12 - Alexander-O'Reilly, Steen farewell tour begins, Hardy-Elgin main event
RADICAN'S ALPHA-1 REVIEW SERIES: "Insanity" (6-29-13) - Elgin-Cairnie, Del Bruno-O'Shea TLC main event
RADICAN'S WWE REVIEW SERIES: "The Best of Raw After The Show" - Rock & Stone Cold hold court in their prime, Taker spinaroonie, Shane & Rock?
RADICAN'S Kayfabe Commentaries Review Series: YouShoot w/ICP - Stories from WWE, WCW, TNA, JCW, music career
RADICAN'S REVIEW SERIES: "A.J. Styles: Leaving An Impact" - frustrations with TNA contract negotiations, in-depth on TNA storylines & management, future on the independents
RADICAN'S AIW REVIEW SERIES: "2014 J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament: Night 1" 5/23 - Bagwell-Sampson, Elgin-Kingston
REFERENCE
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in for Monday's show - did Raw stay above a 3.0 rating this week?
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in for Friday's show
TNA NEWS: Quarter-hour TV ratings for Thursday's Impact
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings for last Thursday's show, plus 2014 ratings average in light of Spike's decision
TITLES & CHAMPS: Ongoing list of 2014 Titleholders (updated 7/28)
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Raw passes 3.0 for first time since Daniel Bryan's injury exit
WWE NEWS: Raw TV rating for last Monday's show vs. MLB Derby
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in for Friday's show
TNA NEWS: Impact quarter-hour ratings - details on last Thursday's show featuring Lashley vs. Hardy
TNA NEWS: Update - TNA Impact TV rating last Thursday
WWE NEWS: Raw vs. Home Run Derby - annual break down of the Derby taking a chunk out of Raw viewership
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - did Friday's show rebound from the Fourth of July?
PWTorch Free Podcast
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/31) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/30) now available - McNeill's All-Star Panel w/Petey Williams & Billy Reil
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (7/29) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (7/28) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/24) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/23) now available - Ezekiel Jackson Interview w/McNeill
LIVECAST AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (7/21) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
LIVECAST AUDIO: Special PWTorch Livecast following Battleground PPV now available - James Caldwell & Jim Valley
LIVECAST AUDIO: Brother Devon Interview w/Jim Valley now available from Friday's PWTorch Livecast
LIVECAST AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/17) now available - James Caldwell's Talk Wrestling
LIVECAST AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/16) now available - Pat McNeill interviews Luke Hawx
LIVECAST AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (7/15) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
VIP Exclusive Features
VIP - 07/31 PWTorch Livecast: James Caldwell & Greg Parks: In-depth discussion of WWE Network's current status & future prospects from all angles, plus what's the true Summerslam main event? (88 min.)
VIP - 07/31 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: In-depth WWE Financials analysis with a particular focus on the state of WWE Network, prospects for future growth, what the numbers likely indicate, plus big picture perspective (44 min.)
VIP - 07/30 Audio Flashback - WWE Vengeance PPV Roundtable (07-11-2004): Mitchell, McNeill, and Keller discuss and debate Edge vs. Orton, Benoit vs. Triple H, Hardy vs. Kane, Batista vs. Jericho, Flair & Eugene team (72 min.)
VIP - 07/30 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: What is the legacy of TNA if it comes to an end this year? Do you think Taker regrets not retiring earlier like Foley recently said? Will Cena get an immediate rematch at Summerslam? (29 min.)
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1365 (PDF & TEXT): Keller's Cover Story and End Notes on TNA-Spike situation, Keller's Pg. 2 Radar on Ventura Verdict and Network Royalties, Mitchell's TNA Memorial Quiz, Parks on Booker T's iPPV
VIP - 07/30 East Coast Cast (ep. #201): TNA's future, Summerslam hype, will Brie vs. Steph "sell PPVs?," more!, plus VIP Conversation (215 min.)
VIP - 07/30 PWTorch Livecast: McNeill's All-Star Panel w/Petey Williams & Billy Reil: Petey's decision to retire, TNA PPV cameo & their TV future, much more!; VIP - News & Events (110 min.)
VIP - 07/29 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Ventura defamation verdict with Ventura's reaction, latest on TNA-Spike, Prince Devitt signing, Raw ratings analysis, SD ratings, more (29 min.)
VIP - 07/29 PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow: Keller & Powell discuss Ventura defamation trial victory, TNA-Spike situation, Reigns or Bryan to headline WM31, should Taker return, WWE Network predictions, Raw reax, live calls, emails (136 min.)
VIP - 07/28 Wade Keller Hotline - WWE Raw: Full rundown & tons of analysis of latest episode with Steph-Brie, more SSlam hype, Jericho-Rollins, plus notes on TNA-Spike & Ventura trial (46 min.)
VIP - 07/28 Caldwell & Parks Breaking News Discussion: In-depth on TNA's TV future, what TNA and Spike are saying, what are TNA's options if not renewed?, more! (50 min.)
VIP - 07/27 Wade Keller Hotline - Breaking News: Spike TV announces Impact Wrestling is cancelled, what does this mean for future of TNA, could they land somewhere else, is GFW a player in this mix, and more analysis (19 min.)