PWTORCH.COM

Select List of Articles by Category Type

SEARCH PWTORCH



CONTACT US

 JUMP TO VIP SITE

VIP SIGN-UP INFO

JUMP TO MMATORCH

UGO AFFILIATE

A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999


PWTorch is customized for your mobile phone such as your Blackberry. Just enter www.pwtorch.com on your phone's browser and choose the "Mobile" option. Samsung Omnia II users, download our free Widget. Apple iPhone users, download our free PWTorch App (search "pwtorch")



 

CALDWELL'S TAKE

CALDWELL: The real story on Eugene (Nick Dinsmore) is not questionable TV content, but Dinsmore himself

Feb 12, 2010 - 11:56:42 AM


Staff08Caldwell_120c_169.jpg
By James Caldwell, Torch assistant editor

Much has been made lately about the "Eugene" mentally-challenged character that was introduced on WWE TV in April 2004.

Videos have circulated to Connecticut media members interested in former WWE CEO Linda McMahon's Senate race showing classic, fun-for-all-ages WWE video clips such as Eugene being destroyed by Triple H in a steel cage.

Hartford Courant's Rick Green even went to McMahon's Senate campaign HQ looking for answers from McMahon herself.

"There was never any intent of WWE to make fun of anyone who is developmentally challenged in any way," McMahon said. "It was to show how you can rise above your circumstances. He always had this quality of believing he could be anything he wanted to be. It's a soap opera. It's all a matter of taste."

McMahon added: I don't want you to mischaracterize what my judgment is. Eugene was an example of the different kinds of issues that can be addressed in life. Here was a fellow who really believed who he was and there were no obstacles to him. It portrayed an element in life that gave hope and inspiration to others."

Ah, yes, the "subjective analysis" of WWE programming argument. It's a disarming argument that calms the issue and doesn't grab headlines or inspire voters to sway one or the other.

What might sway voters or at least expose a scar WWE has tried to cover is the real story about the real person who played the Eugene character.

Eugene was played by Nick Dinsmore, who was a three-strikes-and-you're-out victim of the Wellness Policy. Dinsmore dealt with prescription painkiller addiction while with WWE.

"I always rationalized it as my back hurts, my knee hurts, I can't go out there and perform in pain, so I have to do something about it," Dinsmore said in a February 2009 interview. Read the story.)

Even more troubling was WWE sending Dinsmore on an international tour in late 2005 just days after the death of his close friend, Eddie Guerrero, whose death rushed along the implementation of the current Wellness Policy.

Torch columnist Bruce Mitchell wrote in December 2005 about Dinsmore's pain pill addiction escalating at the time and WWE using him as an example weeks after Guerrero's death.

Nick Dinsmore, who considered Eddie Guerrero a close friend and mentor ever since he recommended him for a spot on the main roster, was not allowed to go to the funeral. Instead, he was forced to make the immediate, arduous trip to England, where he was expected to act out his on camera mentally impaired always happy Eugene character anytime he was seen in public. He made it less than a week, then passed out in a hotel lobby from an overdose of Soma pain pills. He was immediately suspended and sent to rehab. Because of PR considerations in the wake of Guerrero's death, Dinsmore's condition and its consequences were immediately made public in a way that had never happened before.

The real stories in Linda McMahon's Connecticut Senate race are not on the surface with TV content, characters, and storylines. Sure, they're part of the dialogue that has to be included because WWE's TV programming reaches impressionable children who still point to their crotches and yell "suck it!" on school buses (just ask my wife, who teaches Pre-K), but the real stories are below the surface.

Dinsmore's story is not the "Eugene" character, but the prescription pain pills, following "the show must go on" mentality following yet another wrestler death that is still prevalent in today's wrestling industry, and pushing his body when it never should have been pushed.

McMahon has yet to account for the real story on a former WWE star after easily talking down the surface-level story.


Send feedback on this article to pwtorch@gmail.com and we'll regularly publish reader feedback in the "Torch Feedback" category on the Main Listing.

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA...
VISIT OUR AFFILIATE - PROWRESTLING.NET

For UFC & MMA NEWS & BLOGS:
VISIT OUR SISTER SITE - MMATORCH.COM

Upgrade to PWTorch VIP:

 DETAILS & SIGN-UP INFO (VIP Newsletter, Audio, Archives, No Ads on Website, VIP Email Reports, VIP Forum, more.)

More Recent CALDWELL'S TAKE Articles
[an error occurred while processing this directive]

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.

STAFF PICKS - TOP TEN RECENT ARTICLES
THURSDAY'S ASK PWTORCH STAFF: Why didn't WWE use Taker-Lesnar confrontation at UFC? Could TNA benefit from a second show? Is Ziggler's name holding him back? How does end of Streak affect future Manias? Why was Low Ki with LayCool?
CALDWELL'S TNA IMPACT RESULTS 4/17: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Orlando Impact - EY defends TNA Title on first night as Champ, Tag Title match, more
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1351 (PDF & TEXT): WWE holds 60 percent of traditional PPV audience at WM30, new Torch Talk with Steve Austin on Punk, Bryan, Reigns, Mr. T, plus reading between the lines on leaked Raw script
LATEST WWE NEWS: Smackdown SPOILERS, Raw TV ratings, Sting on WWE Network, WM30 buys info, WWE tributes Warrior on Raw, off-air Raw happenings, Extreme Rules line-up, more
AUDIO: "Stone Cold" Steve Austin Interview w/Keller on Thursday's PWTorch Livecast (4/10) now available



PWTORCH FREE AUDIO SHOWS
AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (4/17) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (4/16) now available - Pat McNeill & Jonny Fairplay
AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (4/15) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (4/14) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (4/11) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
AUDIO: "Stone Cold" Steve Austin Interview w/Keller on Thursday's PWTorch Livecast (4/10) now available

PWTORCH INSTANT POLL

TNA IMPACT POLL 4/17: Thursday's show was...
Good Show
Bad Show
Middle of the Road
Did Not Watch Enough To Form Opinion
Did Not Watch The Show
  


MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL: What was the biggest revelation from the leaked WWE Raw script?
A.J. Lee is "injured"
Del Rio was "injured" and wrestled two matches
C.M. Punk is "injured"
Cena's Photoshop bit was not part of the script
Sami Zayn is on the main roster
Steve O. from "Jackass" is on Creative
The announcers need permission to "breathe"
It took three writers to put together the promo Stephanie McMahon decided not to use
Other (email to pwtorchlivecast@gmail.com)
  


D-BRYAN POLL: Among active stars, who should Daniel Bryan's first title defense be against?
Triple H
Randy Orton
Batista
Kane
Bray Wyatt
John Cena
Cesaro
  

VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

UPCOMING MAJOR EVENTS

SELECT LIST OF ARTICLES BY CATEGORY

ARTICLES GROUPED BY CATEGORY
NEWS REPORTS
ALERT - NEW HALF-PRICE VIP SALE - CURRENT VIP MEMBERS TELL YOU WHY YOU SHOULD SIGN UP, WHY IT'S A GREAT COMPANION TO WWE NETWORK
WWE NEWS: Non-Spoiler Smackdown matches for Friday
WWE NEWS: Saudi Arabia tour continues Friday with Cena, Orton, NXT star, more; Reports Wanted
TNA NEWS: Weekend Tour continues Friday - no TNA champ, Tables main event, Joe advertised, Reports Wanted
ROH NEWS: ROH Title match tonight, full Future's Show line-up
IPPV NEWS: Styles & Hardy wrestling on Internet PPV tonight, plus former TNA and ECW star scheduled
WWE NETWORK: Friday, April 18 Schedule (Warrior Week & WM30 Fallout concludes, no Smackdown shows)
SHOW RESULTS - 4/17 WWE in Riyadh, KSA: Cena vs. Orton main-events first show in Saudi Arabia, plus Shield vs. Wyatts
EVENT REPORT - 4/16 Mick Foley Comedy Show in Raleigh, N.C.: Details on Foley's material & Hardy appearance
"TUF: Nations" Finale Wrap-Up: MMATorch coverage of "Bisping vs. Kennedy" event and TUF 19 premiere on Fox Sports 1
IMPACT NEWS: Young defends TNA Title first week as Champ, Angle returns, Tag Titles, X Title, top match next week
GFW VIDEO: Jarrett launches web series "The Journey"
PPV REPORTS
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - WWE WrestleMania 30: Best & Worst Match, Biggest Surprise, What Will Mania Be Remembered For?, Updated 2014 PPV Rankings
WRESTLEMANIA 30 PPV RESULTS (Hour 4): Complete "virtual-time" coverage of WWE Title main event, Divas Title
WRESTLEMANIA 30 PPV RESULTS (Hour 3): Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Undertaker vs. Lesnar Streak match
WRESTLEMANIA 30 PPV RESULTS (Hour 2): Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Cena vs. Bray, big moment for Cesaro in the Andre Battle Royal, Shield vs. Outlaws
WRESTLEMANIA 30 PPV RESULTS (Hour 1): Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Bryan vs. Hunter, Hogan & Austin & Rock open PPV
WRESTLEMANIA 30 PPV RESULTS (Pre-Show): Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Tag Title match, big face turn, more
CALDWELL'S NJPW PPV RESULTS 4/6: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of "Invasion Attack 2014" - Nakamura regains IC Title, A.J. Styles big angle, new NWA tag champions, more
IPPV RESULTS: 4/5 DGUSA "Mercury Rising 2014" - RADICAN'S Report on Gargano vs. Low Ki, six-man tournament, Teddy Hart changes course of entire show, more
IPPV RESULTS - 4/4 DGUSA in New Orleans, La.: RADICAN'S Report on historic main event result, Hero vs. Tanaka, more
IPPV RESULTS - 4/4 Wrestling Odyssey in New Orleans, La.: RADICAN'S report on Hero defending EVOLVE Title, stand-out CZW Title match, more title matches
KYGHT'S PPV EVALUATION - TNA Lockdown: Best/Worst Match, Biggest Surprise/Letdown, updated 2014 PPV Rankings
RADICAN'S ROH "12th Anniversary" Report 2/21: The Decade-Mark Briscoe & Alexander & Page, ReDragon-Adrenaline Rush, Hero-Cole
TV REPORTS
TV REPORT - 4/17 "Legends House" Episode #1: CALDWELL'S Report on introductions, Piper vs. Everyone, more
CALDWELL'S WWE MAIN EVENT RESULTS 4/15: Big Show vs. Swagger, #1 contender Divas Battle Royal, more
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 4/17 - Week 94: NXT champ Neville vs. Brodus main event, Camacho resurfaces, Paige appears as Divas & NXT Women's champ, Overall Reax
CALDWELL'S TNA IMPACT RESULTS 4/17: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Orlando Impact - EY defends TNA Title on first night as Champ, Tag Title match, more
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 4/14: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of live Raw - Warrior tribute, latest WM30 fall-out
METZGER'S ROH TV REPORT 4/12: Lethal captures ROH TV Title and turns heel, The Streak continues
PARKS'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 4/11: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Friday show, including Daniel Bryan & The Usos vs. Kane, Batista, and Randy Orton
JAMES'S WWE SUPERSTARS REPORT 4/10: Kofi vs. Titus main event, Ziggler loses to Ryback
JAMES'S WWE NXT REPORT 4/10 - Week 93: Bo Dallas breaks down, Mojo gets hyped, Neville-Brodus feud continues, more
CALDWELL'S TNA IMPACT RESULTS 4/10: Complete "virtual-time" coverage of Orlando Impact - new TNA World champion
CALDWELL'S TV REPORT: Daniel Bryan's must-see "Journey to WrestleMania 30" WWE Network Special
CALDWELL'S WWE MAIN EVENT RESULTS 4/8: Shield vs. Wyatts six-man tag, Ziggler vs. Swagger, Rusev, WM30 fall-out
OPINION & ANALYSIS
THURSDAY'S ASK PWTORCH STAFF: Why didn't WWE use Taker-Lesnar confrontation at UFC? Could TNA benefit from a second show? Is Ziggler's name holding him back? How does end of Streak affect future Manias? Why was Low Ki with LayCool?
THURSDAY'S ASK PWTORCH STAFF: How does end of Streak affect future Manias? Is Ziggler's name holding him back? Why didn't WWE use Taker-Lesnar confrontation at UFC? Could TNA benefit from a second show? Why was Low Ki with LayCool?
IMPACT POLL 4/17: Vote on Eric Young's first week as Champ
THURSDAY'S ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL: Did Streak end to spite fans for cheering Bryan? Who from TNA could end up in WWE? Could it finally be time for War Games? Will Randy Orton ever get his show-closing WrestleMania Moment?
THURSDAY'S ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL: Could it finally be time for War Games? Will Randy Orton ever get his show-closing WrestleMania Moment? Did Streak end to spite fans for cheering Bryan? Who from TNA could end up in WWE?
WEDNESDAY'S ASK PWTORCH STAFF: What is next for Punk and did he do enough to be a Hall of Famer? Did Dynamite Kid face Savage more than once and was their match scripted? Could IC Title return to past glory? More concussions today?
WEDNESDAY'S ASK PWTORCH STAFF: What's next for Punk and did he do enough to be a Hall of Famer? Did Dynamite Kid face Savage more than once and was their match scripted? Could IC Title return to past glory? More concussions today?
WEDNESDAY’S ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL: What about a Cruiserweight show on WWE Network? Why does the champ still carry both WWE titles? Could the IC Title return to past glory? Is Sandow in the dog house?
WEDNESDAY’S ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL: What about a Cruiserweight show on WWE Network? Why does the champ still carry both WWE titles? Is Sandow in the dog house? Could the IC Title return to past glory?
MCNEILL LIVECAST POLL: What was the biggest revelation from the leaked WWE Raw script?
VOTE: Who should be Daniel Bryan's first title defense?
TUESDAY’S ASK PWTORCH ALL-STAR PANEL: Could Undertaker skip a year and return at WM32 in Dallas? What wrestling moment shocked you the most? Can a heel get over with traditional heat these days? Is it time to turn Cena heel now?
THE SPECIALISTS
TUCKER ON TV: Reviews of Warrior Tribute, "Legends House," NXT on WWE Network Thursday night
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: Network Era Rankings #6, plus evaluation of NXT Prospects
ASK THE SPECIALISTS: Roundtable #2 - is Dolph Ziggler's name or something else holding him back?
HITS & MISSES - 4/14 WWE Raw: RVD vs. Del Rio, Heyman, Cena Discovers Photoshop, Barrett vs. Ziggler, Evolution Reforms
TUCKER ON RAW 4/14: WWE sets the path for Extreme Rules, but is it an interesting path?
ASK THE SPECIALISTS: Introducing a new Roundtable discussion - Installment #1 on whether Punk regrets walking away from WWE
COLLECTIBLES COLUMN: How the Collector's Market Has Reacted to Ultimate Warrior's Death
APR. 14 IN HISTORY: This 1997 Raw episode captures why WWF/E was struggling against WCW
EATON'S PERSPECTIVE OF THE COMMON FAN: WrestleMania 30 Aftermath - Bryan, Youth Movement, Network, more
VALENTINO'S MAGIC, MEMORIES & MANIA - Live At WrestleMania 30 Ratings: From a Magical Opening to the Worst Moment in WrestleMania History
CHIVERTON'S NXT SCOUTING REPORT: New Rankings, plus which Main Roster call-ups are most likely to succeed?
VALENTINO'S MAGIC, MEMORIES, AND MANIA: Live at the 2014 WWE Hall of Fame for Ultimate Warrior's finale, Razor's coolness, and Jake's epic storytelling
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
PWTORCH YOUTUBE EXCLUSIVE: Scott Hall talks 2014 WWE Hall of Fame induction, receiving the news, health, more
CALDWELL'S DVD REVIEW: WWE's "Ultimate Collection" - Jim Hellwig tells his story on the Ultimate Warrior
RADICAN'S DGUSA DVD REVIEW SERIES: "Enter the Dragon 2012" (7-29-12) Gargano-Taylor I Quit match, Generico-Tozawa, Fox & CIMA vs Ricochet & Swann
RADICAN CZW DVD REVIEW SERIES "Cage of Death XV" (12-14-13) - Gulak-Hero, Dickinson-Richards, NOI vs. The Forgotten Ones Cage of Death match
RADICAN'S WRESTLING REVIEW LOG: Comprehensive Reference Guide for the latest wrestling DVD, Book, and Video Game reviews
RADICAN'S AIW REVIEW SERIES: "Hell on Earth 9" (11-29-13) - Steen-Gargano, Hutter-Donst, #Nixon-Team AIW main event
MITCHELL FLASHBACK: His feature column 10 years ago - Surviving Crazy Jonny Fairplay of Survivor and TNA fame
RADICAN'S DVD REVIEW SERIES: "The Kevin Steen Show with Chris Hero" - WWE departure, thoughts on WWE Performance Center, great CZW & IWA-MS stories
RADICAN'S ALPHA-1 REVIEW SERIES: "Rehab" (4-20-13) - Alexander-Fire Ant, Silver-Elgin, Page-Brown
RADICAN'S DGUSA DVD REVIEW SERIES: "Untouchable 2012" (7-28-12) Fox & CIMA vs. Del Sol & Generico, Gargano-Tozawa
EXCLUSIVE AUDIO: Jake "the Snake" Roberts discusses WWE TV return on PWTorch Livecast - when did he find out about "Old School" Raw appearance?, Rumble? Mania send-off?, more
RADICAN'S JCW REVIEW SERIES: "BloodyMania 7" (8-11-13) - Young Bucks-Haters, star studded Rumble Royale, London & Kendrick
REFERENCE
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in for Monday's show
TNA NEWS: Impact quarter-hour TV ratings last Thursday - TNA Title change draws lowest rating of the show
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - how did the first Smackdown after WM30 fare?
TITLES & CHAMPS: Ongoing list of 2014 Titleholders
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in - how did Thursday's show fare with a TNA Title change?
WWE NEWS: Raw TV quarter-hour ratings - Daniel Bryan draws big numbers post-Mania, plus very detailed report on the other segments that boosted Raw
WWE NEWS: TV Rating for Hall of Fame special on USA Network
WWE NEWS: Raw TV ratings are in - Raw surges the night after WrestleMania, hits highest points since Raw 1,000
RAW NEWS: Comparison of post-WM TV ratings last eight years
WWE NEWS: Smackdown TV ratings are in - how did the final Smackdown before WrestleMania fare?
TNA NEWS: Impact quarter-hour TV ratings 4/3 - details on how Thursday night's Impact fared
TNA NEWS: Impact TV ratings are in - Impact still in a rut
PWTorch Free Podcast
AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (4/17) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (4/16) now available - Pat McNeill & Jonny Fairplay
AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (4/15) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (4/14) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (4/11) now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
AUDIO: "Stone Cold" Steve Austin Interview w/Keller on Thursday's PWTorch Livecast (4/10) now available
AUDIO: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (4/9) now available - McNeill hosts All-Star Panel
AUDIO: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (4/8) now available - Wade Keller & Jason Powell of Prowrestling.net
AUDIO: Monday PWTorch Livecast (4/7) now available - Bruce Mitchell & Travis Bryant
AUDIO: Special PWTorch Livecast (4/6) following WWE's WM30 PPV now available - James Caldwell & Greg Parks
AUDIO: Friday PWTorch Livecast (4/4) now available - Zach Gowen Interview w/Wade Keller
AUDIO: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (4/3) now available - James Caldwell & Sean Radican
VIP Exclusive Features
VIP - 04/17 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Was that Punk on stage in a hoodie on Monday? Why didn't Cena vs. Taker happen at WM? Is WWE exploiting Warrior's death for Network content and sales? Plus Lawler, ROH on PPV, start of Hulkamania (27 min.)
VIP - 04/17 PWTorch Livecast (Ad-Free): James Caldwell & Greg Parks: Week in Review including WWE Title picture, Raw script leak, TNA's future, GFW questions to be answered, ROH returning to PPV, more! (110 min.)
VIP - 04/16 East Coast Cast (ep. #186): Random Week produces hoaxes, light bulbs, Mania hangover, and it can't be Bryan vs. Kane, right? (167 min.)
VIP - 04/16 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Do you think Punk congratulated Bryan? Should fans feel cheated who ordered WWE Network to get WM30 now that it's free this week? Brock doesn't need a title reign, right? More (26 min.)
VIP - 04/16 PWTorch Livecast (Ad-Free): Pat McNeill & Jonny Fairplay: A full range of topics - WWE P.R. drama, stock market, Bryan vs. Kane - really?, mystery hand signals, brooms, Broome, Impact to Global?, more!; VIP - News & Events (116 min.)
VIP - PWTorch Newsletter #1351 (PDF & TEXT): WWE holds 60 percent of traditional PPV audience at WM30, new Torch Talk with Steve Austin on Punk, Bryan, Reigns, Mr. T, plus reading between the lines on leaked Raw script
VIP - 04/15 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Putting in perspective the WWE WrestleMania 30 early domestic buyrate figure and what it means to future Network growth, DirecTV pulls PPVs, Raw rating, Sting's WWE TV debut (15 min.)
VIP - 04/15 PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow: Keller & Powell break down headlines coming out of Raw including Bryan's PPV positioning, return of Evolution, Cena's odd promo, plus digesting WM30 buyrate info just released (111 min.)
VIP - 04/14 Wade Keller Hotline - WWE Raw: Full rundown and analysis of Warrior tribute, Evolution reunite against the Shield, Kane finds his mask, IC Title tournament begins, Cena goes back to Photoshopping humor (41 min.)
VIP - 04/13 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Would Daniel Bryan really take a demotion from main events well? Is there a history of heels jumping manager to manager? How does Bryan's win change Money in the Bank? (34 min.)
VIP - 04/12 Wade Keller Hotline - Ask the Editor: Does Lesnar ending Streak offset losses to Cena and Hunter? What happened to ringside photographers? Is Reigns going to be the Next Batista? What about Nancy Grace? (41 min.)
VIP - 04/12 Vintage Audio (20 Yrs. Ago) - Interviews with Paul Heyman and Too Cold Scorpio on John Arezzi's Pro Wrestling Spotlight show in New York with Heyman's views on early ECW, Scorpio on high-flying wrestlers, WCW politics (96 min.)