PWTORCH.COM
VIP SIGN-UP JUMP TO VIP
CONTACT US VISIT MMA TORCH

Select List of Articles by Category Type



UGO AFFILIATE

A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999


PWTorch is customized for your mobile phone such as your Blackberry. Just enter www.pwtorch.com on your phone's browser and choose the "Mobile" option. Samsung Omnia II users, download our free Widget. Apple iPhone users, download our free PWTorch App (search "pwtorch")




 

CALDWELL'S TAKE

CALDWELL: Survivor Series PPV analysis - Winners & Losers & Question marks heading into tonight's Raw

Nov 23, 2009 - 4:44:15 PM


Staff08Caldwell_120c_78.jpg
By James Caldwell, Torch assistant editor

I'm with most Torch readers that last night's Survivor Series PPV was a satisfying PPV event, but not a blow-away event. It was right at expectations with some strong surprises such as Shawn Michaels's superkick on Triple H and the heavy emphasis on the young stars. More on the HBK superkick in a second.

Reading through Reax feedback from Torch readers, the scores have averaged out to about a 7.0, reflecting a hearty thumbs up. Also, in our post-PPV poll, Torch readers voted 34 percent on being satisfied and 28 percent on being very satisfied with the show. The total for disappointment was 20 percent. The PPV was essentially like patting your stomach and pulling away from the table after a solid meal at Cracker Barrel.

Let's make sense of what happened at the PPV to see who or what were the big winners, losers, and question marks coming into tonight's Raw.

Winners

-- Kofi Kingston. Clearly, Kingston is a future babyface star on the Raw brand. WWE certainly positioned him that way with the pins on former World champs C.M. Punk and Randy Orton (with heavy emphasis on that fact from the announcers) in a span of six seconds. So much of the science of elevating a star is who he is related to. If Orton wasn't a big star with about 15 WWE PPV main events on his resume from the last two years, Kofi's sudden push wouldn't mean as much. If Punk wasn't in recent programs with Jeff Hardy and The Undertaker battling over the World Title, then Kofi pinning Punk wouldn't have been as big of a deal. WWE executed a flawless gameplan elevating Kofi in the marquee Survivor Series match. What's Next: Looks like a TLC match against Randy Orton.

-- Christian. The secondary story coming out of the Kofi-Orton Survivor Series match was WWE presenting Christian as a headline talent from the ECW brand. Most people will remember his backstage rap before the match. He also delivered a strong performance during the Survivor Series match as part of the focus on the Kofi-Orton issues. Since all three brands are on Raw tonight, I wouldn't be surprised to see him opposite Randy Orton (who pinned Christian at the PPV) in a singles match or tag match tonight to continue elevating Christian for a future top spot on Raw or Smackdown. What's Next: Back to ECW for a program against who knows who over the ECW Title.

-- Miz, Sheamus, and McIntyre. Sheamus and McIntyre stood out more than The Miz in the opening match because of the amount of devastating-looking offense they had, but Miz was portrayed as a strong leader for the second straight PPV. Miz was the only wrestler from Team Raw to win a match at Bragging Rights, then he was booked to look strong at Survivor Series. What's Next: The pipe dream of Miz forming a stable/faction with the likes of Sheamus and/or Drew McIntyre is unlikely. Most likely is Miz continuing his U.S. Title program with Jack Swagger or Evan Bourne. WWE could always re-visit the Cena vs. Miz program with the "champion vs. champion" element, but that's worth saving for 2010. Meanwhile, Sheamus will continue running folks over on Raw and McIntyre could be in an IC Title program with John Morrison by December.

-- Batista. Big Dave looked like a monster taking apart Rey Mysterio, who continues his streak of elevating talent on the way out the door. After having an amazing Smackdown TV match with John Morrison before serving a suspension in October, Rey took a beating like a pro to make Batista seem like a badass. Batista's character is refreshed and we're probably looking at Batista running with the World Title again. What's Next: Looks like a World Title program with the banged up Undertaker.

-- WWE Title. After WWE played hot potato with John Cena and Randy Orton for months, someone finally retained the WWE Title when Cena was booked to defeat Shawn Michaels and Triple H. Perhaps Cena will - gasp! - hold the belt until 2010 to make a title change mean something down the road. It won't be popular with many readers, but Cena holding the belt for a while will be a good thing. What's Next: See question marks.

-- Carlito. Can't get on the PPV? Hope that someone in the audience makes a sign. The "Where's Carlito?" sign was the most we've seen from Carlito on PPV in months. What's Next: "Where's Festus?" sign next month.

LOSERS

-- Big Show, Undertaker, Rey Mysterio injured. All three men are banged up. Show is scheduled for surgery. Rey Mysterio is scheduled for extended time off. Taker just wrestled a grueling international schedule earlier this month and his body language says he's holding on by a thread. The year-round schedule and physical toll in the ring has caught up to all three men. It showed on Sunday when Show and Taker slogged through a match with Chris Jericho doing most of the work.

-- Dolph Ziggler. Dolph is like the Buffalo Bills times 100 with WWE booking him to lose championship match after championship match. Then, he was the first one eliminated from the Survivor Series opening match. Dolph is looking like a "flavor of the month" right now with WWE appearing to be much higher on McIntyre right now from the group of young heels on the Smackdown brand.

-- Announcers. Michael Cole had one of his better days at the office, especially the emphasis on Kofi Kingston's rapid-fire pins on Punk and Orton. However, the combo of Cole, Jerry Lawler, and Matt Striker was rough throughout the night. Striker's long sentences filled with multiple-syllable words followed by Cole and/or Lawler asking what he was saying became an annoying pattern by the middle of the second hour. WWE is trying to fight the right combinations for these PPVs, but Todd Grisham was missing to settle things down from the Smackdown side.

QUESTION MARKS

-- DX split? One of the big question marks for tonight's Raw is whether WWE acknowledges Triple H and Shawn Michaels's apparent DX breakup or sends them back on TV as if nothing happened. Certainly, Jesse Ventura will have something to say investigating this conspiracy. Tonight's Raw should give us an indication of the direction WWE is going with a possible Hunter-Michaels feud.

-- Next title contenders? John Cena has gone through Randy Orton and now Shawn Michaels and Triple H. It seems likely WWE will re-book the Survivor Series main event in an HBK specialty match involving a ladder at the TLC PPV, though. I say that because it seems unlikely WWE will be looking to give away Michaels vs. Hunter on an "off-brand PPV" with only three weeks in-between events. As for Undertaker, it seems pretty obvious Batista is next in line against Taker.

-- Unified tag titles status? Big Show is scheduled for surgery this week, but it's unclear if that will require days, weeks, or months to recover from. Tonight's Raw could give us new tag champs or WWE could simply find a replacement for Show. How WWE puts together the DX and Unified tag title puzzle pieces should determine the top matches for the TLC PPV coming up in three weeks.


Send feedback on this article to pwtorch@gmail.com and we'll regularly publish reader feedback in the "Torch Feedback" category on the Main Listing.

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA...
VISIT OUR AFFILIATE - PROWRESTLING.NET


For UFC & MMA NEWS & BLOGS:
VISIT OUR SISTER SITE - MMATORCH.COM

Upgrade to PWTorch VIP:

DETAILS & SIGN-UP INFO (rates now as low as $2.99/month)

More Recent CALDWELL'S TAKE Articles
CALDWELL: Instant analysis on WWE Raw - HBK's performance, Hart-McMahon build-up, John Cena locked in
CALDWELL: After listening to Hulk Hogan on RVD's radio show, it's apparent TNA will take off or self-destruct
CALDWELL'S WEEKLY CHAT w/GREG PARKS - Raw & Rumble reviews, WM26 direction, EC PPV qualifiers, Bret Hart performance, R-Truth push, Pants on the Ground
CALDWELL: Morning-after Royal Rumble analysis - WWE's potential paths to a WrestleMania 26 PPV line-up
CALDWELL'S BLOG: WWE Royal Rumble PPV match previews in a sentence
CALDWELL: Quick reaction to TNA's record rating on Thursday night
CALDWELL'S VIP BLOG: Atlanta rewarded for Georgia not regulating WWE two years ago
CALDWELL'S DAILY BLOG 1/28: Jericho & Helms overview, WWE drops Hurricane as Superstar of the Day, WrestleReunion ad on WWE TV, Luger talks WWE vs. TNA
CALDWELL'S VIP BLOG: The picture isn't pretty as more details surface on Jericho & Helms arrest
CALDWELL'S WEEKLY CHAT w/GREG PARKS - Raw Review, Royal Rumble build-up, Hair cuts, Mickie-McCool, Rumble Final Four and Picks
CALDWELL'S DVD REVIEW - "The Marine 2" strong on DiBiase's performance, weak on plot and storyline
CALDWELL: Broader perspective on the TNA Impact ratings, where TNA should be two months from now
CALDWELL'S DAILY BLOG 1/22: Back-story on Benoit & Guerrero jumping to WWE, PG TV?, Murdoch & Harley, Sapolsky and Corino interviews, Styles talks comics
CALDWELL'S DAILY BLOG 1/21: Torch Back-Issue News Item of the Day, The Rock on ESPN Radio, Jericho magazine cover, Sapolsky blog
CALDWELL: Shawn Michaels vs. The Undertaker or Triple H at WrestleMania 26? The case for each headline match
CALDWELL'S DAILY BLOG 1/20: Raw TV ratings, Linda McMahon announcement, Cornette on vicious wrestling cycle, The Rock talks new movie (w/VIDEO)
CALDWELL'S DAILY BLOG 1/19: TNA pulls "cast member" video, Analysis of WWE Studios change, Jerry Springer on Raw, L.A. Times covers Kiffin Raw reference
CALDWELL'S WEEKLY CHAT w/GREG PARKS - Every major WWE TV subject covered: Hunter-HBK, Rey-Taker, Bret Hart's return, C.M. Punk payoff
CALDWELL: Reaction to Genesis PPV - TNA delivers middle-of-the-road, not-too-frustrating PPV to start 2010
CALDWELL: Mr. Kennedy would not fit Hulk Hogan's description for the super surprise at tonight's Genesis PPV

(c) 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.

STAFF PICKS - TOP TEN RECENT ARTICLES
TNA News: Hulk Hogan responds to criticism that TNA looks like "WCW 2000," addresses hardcore fans critical of TNA's direction
WWE/TNA News: RVD in-depth interview - what could convince him to consider TNA offer, talks WWE subjects, current projects
WWE News: Vince McMahon's ECW announcement - ECW going off the air
WWE News: Raw TV ratings are in for Monday night's show - How did WWE fare with Bret Hart's return?
Other News: Former NWA World Hvt. champion Jack Brisco dies at age 68
TNA News: Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff say they haven't confirmed permanent Monday night slot
TNA News: Vince Russo apologizes for blog on "fake wrestling in a fake sport," sheds more light on why he writes what he writes for TNA TV
WWE News: Chris Jericho and Gregory Helms arrested early Wednesday morning (1/27); Details on their arrest
WWE News: "The Rock" Dwayne Johnson must-read interview on "ripping up" the TV product if he returns to WWE; has no interest in wrestling John Cena
WWE News: Big News: The Rock says on ESPN SportsCenter he will not rule out wrestling again, snaps into character with The Coach (w/VIDEO)



PWTORCH FREE AUDIO SHOWS
Monday PWTorch Livecast (2/8) now available featuring Wade Keller & Greg Parks
Friday PWTorch Livecast (2/5) now available featuring Wade Keller & Bruce Mitchell
Thursday PWTorch Livecast (2/4) now available featuring Wade Keller & James Caldwell
Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (2/3) now available featuring Wade Keller & Pat McNeill
Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (2/2) now available featuring Wade Keller & Greg Parks
Monday PWTorch Livecast (2/1) now available featuring Wade Keller & Jason Powell



PWTORCH INSTANT POLL

RAW POLL: Who was the MVP of the 2/8 Raw if you saw the show?
John Cena
Vince McMahon
Bret Hart
Shawn Michaels
Triple H
Randy Orton
Cody Rhodes
Carl Edwards
The Miz
Big Show
C.M. Punk
Luke Gallows & Serena
Christian
Sheamus
Ted DiBiase
Santino
Maryse
Gail Kim
Subway Jared
Carlito
  
Free polls from Pollhost.com

VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

UPCOMING MAJOR EVENTS

SELECT LIST OF ARTICLES BY CATEGORY

ARTICLES GROUPED BY CATEGORY
WWE RAW 2/8: Place Your Bets on tonight's Raw - Week 6 guest-hosted by Carl Edwards
WWE RAW 2/1: "Place your Bets" Scoreboard after Week 5 - Review last week's scores before tonight's PYB contest
TORCH MONTHLY AWARD VOTING: Results for Best/Worst in pro wrestling from January 2010
WWE News: WWE teases Bret Hart vs. Vince McMahon for WM26, Hart makes surprise appearance on Raw
WWE News: Three big singles matches including John Cena vs. Triple H booked for next week's Raw
WWE News: First WWE 2010 Hall of Fame inductee announced
TNA News: Inside the Impact quarter-hour ratings - 33 percent Q1 drop from Jan. 28 to Feb. 4
TNA News: Latest TNA Impact ratings down 15 percent, Analysis of the drop-off
WWE/TNA News: Shane Douglas talks WWE sanitizing the ECW brand to kill "ECW" chants, says TNA has "produced nothing," has other harsh words for TNA
ROH News: Preview for tonight's ROH TV - TNA tag team vs. former ROH tag champs, 8th Anniversary hype (w/VIDEO)
ROH News: Roderick Strong re-signs contract agreement with ROH
ROH News: ROH's 8th Anniv. show preview - ROH Title & ROH Tag Title matches, First-Time-Ever ROH match
Other News: Samoa Joe, Hernandez, former WWE wrestlers booked for independent show in March
Other News: Independent wrestler Human Tornado retiring from pro wrestling (w/classic Tornado VIDEO)
DGUSA/EVOLVE News: Sapolsky blogs on hectic week, TNA allowing Young Bucks to work WM weekend
WWE Royal Rumble Results: KELLER'S in-depth report including Rumble results, Taker vs. Rey, Orton vs. Sheamus
CALDWELL'S WWE ROYAL RUMBLE PPV REPORT 1/31: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage Rumble match, Sheamus vs. Orton, Undertaker vs. Mysterio
RADICAN'S DGUSA "Freedom Fight" PPV review - Yamato-Richards, Doi & Yoshino vs. Dragon Kid & Shingo
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW REPORT 2/8: Complete coverage of Unified tag title match, WWE champ vs. ECW champ, Hart-McMahon
KELLER'S TNA IMPACT REPORT 2/4: Nash vs. Foley (really) headlines, plus Angelina Love vs. Tara, Magnus vs. Mr. Anderson, Styles vs. Pope
PARKS' WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 2/5: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of the show, including Undertaker on the Cutting Edge
2/6 WWE in Alexandria, La.: Sheamus vs. John Cena, The Miz vs. MVP, Jack Swagger's first win of 2010
2/6 TNA in Joplin, Mo.: Jeff Jarrett vs. Mr. Anderson IV, Tara vs. ODB with Shark Boy, Sabin vs. Lethal
2/6 WWE in Waco, Tex.: Rey Mysterio vs. C.M. Punk, McIntyre vs. Morrison vs. R-Truth, Christian vs. Zeke
TORCH TALK DAILY with Eric Bischoff: Bischoff praises UFC's "The Ultimate Fighter" TV series
TORCH TALK DAILY with Eric Bischoff: Bischoff on whether he regrets not buying UFC in the late '90s
PENICK'S UFC 109 PPV REPORT: Play-by-play on tonight's UFC PPV event (redirect)
KELLER'S WWE RAW REPORT 2/8: Bret Hart appears again after John Cena reveals to McMahon that Bret wants him one-on-one at WrestleMania
KELLER'S VIP BLOG: A ratings experiment for TNA to try with the Knockouts
KELLER: Vince Russo owes wrestlers another apology, plus one to the fans
MITCHELL: Jack Brisco, NWA Champion - A look at his life and his career
MITCHELL: Mojo Mitchell's 2/1 Raw Stream of The Return of Captain Kirk, The Green Goblin, and The Lonesome Dove
MITCHELL: Mojo Mitchell's Raw Stream of Lining His Pockets and Serving his Ego with All of Us Commodities
There Can Be Only One: McNEILL Previews the 2010 WWE Royal Rumble!
Calling All Stations: McNEILL previews TNA Genesis 2010!
It's On, Brother: McNEILL previews TNA Final Resolution 2009!
CALDWELL: Instant analysis on WWE Raw - HBK's performance, Hart-McMahon build-up, John Cena locked in
CALDWELL: After listening to Hulk Hogan on RVD's radio show, it's apparent TNA will take off or self-destruct
CALDWELL'S WEEKLY CHAT w/GREG PARKS - Raw & Rumble reviews, WM26 direction, EC PPV qualifiers, Bret Hart performance, R-Truth push, Pants on the Ground
RADICAN'S VIP BLOG: What's going on with Davey Richards?
RADICAN'S VIP BLOG: An overhaul to the ECW brand could benefit young talent
RADICAN'S BLOG: Thoughts on ROH's GBH VIII, TNA's big budget blunders, more
2/5 WWE Smackdown Hits & Misses: Jericho - Edge, Match Quality, The Cutting Edge
GARDNER'S KEY MOMENT OF THE WEEK: 2010 Royal Rumble - A look at what worked, what didn't work, what could be improved
ABSURDITY OF IT ALL - TNA Impact: Nash and Foley Fight Over a Painting, Farewell Big Poppa Pump, TNA Bringing in Evil Dave Hebner?
GUEST EDITORIAL: The End of an Error for the ECW brand, What to do with ECW's current stars
GUEST EDITORIAL: Proposal on how to use the ECW timeslot to create innovative TV feeding Raw & Smackdown
GUEST EDITORIAL - CD REVIEW: WWE's new album features work-out quality jams, awful tracks, screeching guitar solos
TNA Impact Reax #3: Reader feedback on Mick Foley, Mr. Anderson on the mic, Taz referencing WWE, Pope as the "best WWE cast-off"
Thursday Night TV Reax #2: Reader feedback on Impact storylines, missing X Division, Carlito-Bourne match
TNA Impact Reax #1: First batch of reader feedback on Nash-Foley main event, Pope pinning the champ, Eric Bischoff's performance
Ask the Editor: Wouldn't incorporating MMA-style holds into pro wrestling matches just be trying to be something it's not?
ASK THE EDITOR: Have the Michaels-Batista promos crossed a line with use of insider terms, references to "jobs"?
ASK THE EDITOR: Why do wrestlers in WWE refer to wrestling as "the business" and not "the sport"?
GUEST EDITORIAL - CD REVIEW: WWE's new album features work-out quality jams, awful tracks, screeching guitar solos
CALDWELL'S DVD REVIEW - "The Marine 2" strong on DiBiase's performance, weak on plot and storyline
RADICAN'S ROH DVD REVIEW SERIES: 10/9 "Clash of the Contenders" - Omega-Richards, Delirious-Aries
TORCH FLASHBACK (1999): Mankind wins the WWF Title at Halftime Heat during Super Bowl
WWE ROYAL RUMBLE COUNTDOWN - 2009 PPV Report: Randy Orton wins the Rumble, Jeff Hardy vs. Edge, Jack Swagger vs. Matt Hardy
WWE ROYAL RUMBLE COUNTDOWN - 2008 PPV Report: John Cena surprise Rumble win at MSG, Randy Orton vs. Jeff Hardy, MVP vs. Flair
2/8 PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow: Wade Keller & Greg Parks take caller and email questions, analyze Impact ratings drop, Bret Hart's main event run, more (75 min.)
2/7 Bruce Mitchell Audio Show (pt. 3 of 3): Even more on Jack Brisco, evolution of 1970s-to-'80s industry, his stint in the WWF, cable expansion (49 min.)
2/6 Bruce Mitchell Audio Show (pt. 2 of 3): Remembering Jack Brisco, a fascinating look at the 1970s through early-'80s industry (48 min.)
TORCH TRIVIA 2/28: Which wrestler backed out of a WWA PPV in February 2002?
TORCH TRIVIA 2/27: Who said this quote about Hulk Hogan's athleticism 11 years ago?
TORCH TRIVIA 2/25: What said this quote about WWE's mid-1990s drug testing policy?
RAW POLL: Who was the MVP of the 2/8 Raw if you saw the show?
ECW POLL: What do you consider the end of "ECW?"
SMACKDOWN POLL: Who was the MVP of the 2/5 Smackdown if you saw the show?
Monday PWTorch Livecast (2/8) now available featuring Wade Keller & Greg Parks
Friday PWTorch Livecast (2/5) now available featuring Wade Keller & Bruce Mitchell
Thursday PWTorch Livecast (2/4) now available featuring Wade Keller & James Caldwell
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 1999 - Muchnick, Rick Rude, Owen Hart, Renegade...
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2000 - Solie, Albright, Duncum, Tsuruta, Blue Demon, Al Costello
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2001: Johnny Valentine, Terry Gordy, Chris Adams, Bertha Faye, Helen Hart