PWTORCH.COM
VIP SIGN-UP JUMP TO VIP
CONTACT US VISIT MMA TORCH




Select Next Article by Category



WE ARE A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999




Pro Wrestling Illustrated

Support Our Sponsor: PWI!

===========================

CHECK OUT OUR AFFILIATE WRESTLING NEWS SITE - THE FASTEST GROWING PRO WRESTLING SITE IN 2008! (click on logo)

prowrestling.NET




CALDWELL'S TAKE
CORNER CUBE THURSDAY 7/3 - For one week, WWE challenges ideal image of World champion
Jul 3, 2008 - 5:57:30 PM


Email This Article- Contact Us - VIP Sign-Up - Back to Home Page

| subscribe to this feed

By James Caldwell, PWTorch columnist

Updated daily from the corner cubicle, Torch columnist James Caldwell's weekday blog focuses on hot topic current events and other items of interest from around wrestling.

Updated Thursday, July 3, 2008

Chris Bell's "Bigger, Stronger, Faster" documentary has added a considerable amount of information to the dialogue on steroids and the idea that larger-than-life physiques are required for prominent sports athletes. The documentary comes to Houston this weekend, so I'll have a chance to watch the movie and post a review next week.

But, the requirement for a certain look has been challenged by WWE this week. I've seen feedback and various columns written this week about Punk "not looking the part" of World Heavyweight champion. He doesn't look tough. He doesn't wrestle tough. He doesn't have the star-quality of Batista, Triple H, or John Cena. He's simply a likeable star who relates to a certain demographic.

Depending on whether Punk holds the title for just a week or actually has an extended title reign, WWE has an opportunity to re-educate the audience on what "looking the part" means. I've also seen it written that Punk's title victory is similar to WWE putting the belt on the kid-friendly and average-sized Bret Hart in the early 1990s when the company was in the midst of an investigation by the federal government.

The context is different, with WWE simply looking to boost interest in the product and capture the younger demographic by placing youthful stars in prominent positions as champions. The result, though, is WWE marketing a drug-free, steroid-free, likeable C.M. Punk as the face of the Raw brand for now.

The benefit to WWE is being able to point to Punk if questions arise as to whether WWE is still pushing larger-than-life bodybuilders as top stars. Are they investing TV time and money on wrestlers based on skill and substance or 20" biceps?

WWE putting the World Title on Punk certainly wasn't just an altruistic move to enhance Punk's career. It has many benefits to the company in terms of marketing and corporate-enhancement.

But, for at least one week, WWE has shown commitment to changing the definition of what a World Heavyweight champion is supposed to look like. Just like Bell's documentary seeks to ask the question of why American culture has created an unhealthy prerequisite for athletes needing to be larger-than-life at any cost, WWE is at least introducing new evidence.

Rey Mysterio held the belt two years ago, with the same questions arising about his size and "not looking the part." If WWE is committed, it will take time for the audience to take an average-sized wrestler seriously as World champion. It will take time for the audience to spend money on a wrestler who isn't the size of Batista or is respected like Triple H.

It is encouraging, though, for the industry leader to focus on an average-sized champion. Whether it's for one week, for corporate-enhancement purposes, or simply for a quick marketing fix to drum up interest in the product, WWE is at least working to re-educate the audience that a World Heavyweight champion's make-up doesn't have to be limited to size and muscles, but it can also be focused on skill and marketability.

***

Updated Wednesday, July 2, 2008

July 1 marked three years since I embarked on a journey as full-time PWTorch.com columnist. I'm not bringing back 31 Days of Caldwell for those of you still remember the glory days (channeling Larry Zbyszko) from July 2005, but it's nice to be able to discuss a newsworthy, eventful, hope-inspiring, and overall entertaining episode of TV that aired two nights ago.

Raw was everything ECW was not last night. ECW felt like the re-run formula show we've watched for months and months. There was nothing wrong with Week 1 of Mark Henry as ECW champion, but a program against the firm of Dreamer & Delaney won't inspire must-see TV going forward. Then again, who else could he feud against?

Matt Hardy is still stuck on Chavo, unfortunately. Finlay and Hornswoggle are still working the same kid-friendly tag match formula against the champs. Meanwhile, new talent is being brought on board, but Atlas don't-call-me-Da-Bone Ortiz was only slightly impressive in his national TV debut. There just isn't much in the way of talent on ECW. Thus, we're left with the men trying to stick their fingers in each of the many holes on the ECW ship.

Raw, on the other hand, was inspiring TV. The youth movement officially began, and WWE really gave the likes of Punk, Kofi, and DiBiase & Cody an opportunity to be significant players in WWE going forward.

The drawback is them acquiring gold by deceit or unjust means, as if they're not good enough to be champions on merit. However, it gives them a foundation to build from and prove they are worthy of title gold. That's where it becomes interesting to follow the next few weeks and months.

Will people spend money to watch a PPV headlined by C.M. Punk, though? Right now, probably not. But, if WWE sticks with the script and is dedicated to the youth over the long-haul, people will eventually recognizes the younger talent as worthy of their money.

Fortunately, WWE has an all-star cast of proven stars on Raw to help sell PPVs even without gold on the line. Chris Jericho vs. Shawn Michaels has been WWE's best and most-consistent program since WrestleMania. WWE inserting that match into a headline slot at the Great American Bash PPV is a smart decision to boost whatever title match presumably features World Hvt. champion C.M. Punk.

Going into the second-half of the year, WWE has set up Raw to be successful. The key, as always, is follow-up. Week after week. How do they create compelling TV without the fall-out from a good PPV and exciting Draft? How do they create compelling TV when Punk isn't cashing in a briefcase in one of those memorable, "transcendent" moments? That's what makes it entertaining to wait and see.

***

Updated Monday, June 30, 2008

Last night's Night of Champions PPV delivered quality, fundamentally-sound wrestling throughout the show and two very strong main events to close the show. Triple H and John Cena didn't deliver the "transcendent moment" that was part of the pre-match hype, but they performed an outstanding WWE main event style title match.

Transcendent moments are difficult to come by in pro wrestling. WWE delivers 14 PPVs per year. TNA delivers 12. WWE has five hours of original programming to fill each week. TNA has two hours. Unless we're talking WrestleMania, Summerslam, or the Royal Rumble, it's difficult to have a moment on PPV that stands the test of time.

It didn't help that the pre-match hype on TV was overshadowed by the Draft and McMahon's money segments that ended with an injury angle. Hunter vs. Cena was back-seated on Raw last week and the match probably won't be discussed after tonight's TV. Hunter will be on Smackdown, while Cena will probably begin a program in some capacity with Batista on Raw.

Contrast that to the last "transcendent moment" from WWE when Michaels superkicked Flair at WrestleMania. Michaels vs. Flair was reinforced by leading into a three-month program involving Michaels, Batista, and Jericho that is still current.

Setting aside WWE over-playing the epic nature of Hunter vs. Cena on an off-month PPV, WWE created several opportunities to focus on the mid-card. There is an apparent love/hate relationship between Vince McMahon & writing crew and the mid-card & tag divisions that you never know from week-to-week whether the wrestlers below the top tier will be given quality TV time.

That will surely change tonight when the top singles champion on Raw is currently Kofi Kingston. No one would have expected that seven days ago, but here's an opportunity for WWE to incorporate Kofi into one of WWE's top programs the last two months with him working with Michaels against Jericho and Lance Cade.

The tag division has a fresh start with DiBiase, Jr. and the now-heel Cody Rhodes dominating the division. After WWE ran the Spirit Squad into the ground two years ago, they have an opportunity to learn from the booking mistakes of that young, brash, cocky heel group and develop this second-generation stable into future stars.

WWE may not have delivered the transcendent moment last night, but they created opportunity for the flagship Raw show to have a nice balance of top-heavy talent and mid-card youth. Cena, Batista, and Michaels will be carrying the top-half of the show, while Kofi, Rhodes, and DiBiase, Jr. could anchor those third and sixth-quarter hours usually reserved for throwaway action. Follow-up will be key, and WWE shouldn't let the McMahon injury angle overshadow an opportunity to build for the future.


Download Audio Sample:

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA, ROH
visit our affiliate: JASON POWELL'S PROWRESTLING.NET

For UFC AND MMA NEWS & BLOGS
visit our affiliate: MMATORCH.COM - now featuring the MMATorch Daily Audio Update!

REACT TO THIS STORY IN OUR FREE PWTORCH FORUM

PWTORCH VIP SIGN-UP INFO - NO ADS, EXCLUSIVE CONTENT

| subscribe to this feed

CALDWELL'S TAKE
Latest Articles by Category
CORNER CUBE THURSDAY 9/4 - Should I stay or should I go? Gail Kim's options
CORNER CUBE TUESDAY 9/2 - Thoughts on Raw with HBK-Jericho, Kane-Rey, and the next C.M. Punk
CORNER CUBE TUESDAY 8/26 - Raw delivered highlights, but was heavy on filler
CORNER CUBE MONDAY 8/18 - Shawn Michaels showed strength, not weakness by not attacking Jericho
CORNER CUBE WEDNESDAY 8/13 - Finally, Matt Striker has found his calling with ECW on Tuesday nights
CORNER CUBE TUESDAY 8/12 - Punk vs. JBL an example of the basics done right
CORNER CUBE WEDNESDAY 8/6 - WWE has tough questions to answer on international expansion
CORNER CUBE WEDNESDAY 7/30 - Playing dominoes with Mike Adamle and Todd Grisham
CORNER CUBE TUESDAY 7/29 - It's Chris Jericho's world and we're just living in it
CORNER CUBE WEDNESDAY 7/23 - ECW, where have you been all my life?
CORNER CUBE MONDAY 7/21 - Understanding WWE's method to the Cena-JBL madness
CORNER CUBE THURSDAY 7/17 - "Bigger, Stronger, Faster*" review: Most-important movie you'll see this year

(c) 1999-2008 TDH Communications Inc. - All rights reserved.

Latest Free Podcasts
PWTorch Free Podcast
9/5 VIP East Coast Audio: Impact - An improvement over last week, Styles tells Sting what needed to be said (85 min.)
9/3 Nostalgia Audio: Nostalgia News, This week in wrestling history, WCW Monday Nitro
9/2 Daily Keller Hotline: Detailed analysis of Monday's Raw segment by segment (29 min.)
9/3 VIP East Coast Audio: ECW - Final ECW hype for Unforgiven, Dirtsheet delivers, Ricky O catching on (54 min.)
WWE Raw 9/1 Post-game Show: Caldwell and Penick discuss Raw (6 min. clip)
8/31 Nostalgia Audio: Remembering Killer Kowalski, Tony Schiavone, and independent contractor status





LATEST PRO WRESTLING TORCH NEWSLETTER #1040 (18 PAGES)

This issue begins with a cover story by Wade Keller looking at the final scene of SummerSlam and why it's bad for WWE not in and of itself, but due to the context it's put in... In-depth coverage of the WWE SummerSlam PPV including Keller's match report with star ratings and the newsletter-exclusive Roundtable Reviews and Reader Reax... Jason Powell's "Page 2 Buzz" with scoops and insider analysis on Mick Foley, TNA's expiring contracts, and more... Bruce Mitchell's Memo further reviews the latest Ric Flair DVD... WWE Newswire, TNA Newswire, and ROH Newswire with insider news, big story analysis, and notebook tidbits... Plus Keller's reports on Raw, Smackdown, and Impact, the Top 5 Stories of the Week, and more... PDF EXCLUSIVE features include the Jon Mezzera's Weekly Hits & Misses and Greg Parks' look at SummerSlam and Smackdown...

INFO ON SUBSCRIPTION TO NEWSLETTER AND AD-FREE VIP SITE

DOWNLOAD RECENT (5-10-08) SAMPLE OF PWTORCH NEWSLETTER (PDF)


PWTORCH READER POLL

What are your thoughts on the WWE Championship Scramble concept?
Big thumbs up. I'm excited to see it.
Tentative thumbs up. I'll need to see it first.
Tentative thumbs down. It sounds like a mess.
Big thumbs down. A disaster in the making.
I have no idea. I'm totally confused by it.
  


VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

UPCOMING EVENTS LISTING

Articles Grouped by Category
Torch Today
TORCH NEWS TICKER 9/5: Mickie on USA tonight, Reports Wanted, Nash and Joe interview, Henry previews Unforgiven, WWE vs. Youtube
TORCH NEWS TICKER 8/29: Kowalski fundraiser, WWE lawsuit update, Midway Q&A on TNA video game, ROH Notes
TORCH NEWS TICKER 8/22: Results Wanted, Austin return date, Batista comments on Cena match, Kofi and DDP interviews
WWE News
WWE News: Raw ratings for Labor Day edition with Michaels-Jericho contract signing
TNA News: Mick Foley confirms he has come to terms on a deal with TNA, plus discusses other aspirations
WWE News: Mick Foley's bio officially removed from WWE.com Smackdown online roster
TNA News
TNA News: Latest on Gail Kim, as her future remains up in the air (w/Keller Analysis)
TNA News: Mick Foley confirms he has come to terms on a deal with TNA, plus discusses other aspirations
TNA New: Impact Ratings down up against Obama speech, Sting's big speech draws top rating of show (w/Keller Analysis)
ROH News
Interview Highlights: Roderick Strong on his stint with TNA, lagging promo skills, indys working together
7/25 ROH in Toronto: "That show was the first thing to make me proud to be a wrestling fan in a LONG time."
ROH News: Lance Storm interview on working with ROH wrestlers and injuries in pro wrestling
Other News
Torch Indy Weekend Results: Low Ki in PWG and new tag champs, Albright, Nunzio, Rhino
Obit: Walter "Killer" Kowalski dead at the age of 81 - wrestling star and trainer of many
Torch Indy Weekend Preview: Steen in IWS, Shiozaki in FIP, Delirious in Elite Pro
PPV Reports
CALDWELL'S WWE SUMMERSLAM REPORT 8/17: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of live PPV
KELLER'S WWE SUMMERSLAM REPORT 8/17: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of live PPV event
KELLER'S TNA HARD JUSTICE PPV REPORT 8/10: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of event - Samoa Joe vs. Booker T in cage
TV Reports
9/4 TNA Impact Recap by Wilkenfeld: Sting, AJ, and Christian try to save the show from itself
9/2 ECW on Sci-Fi Report: Mayer's "alt perspective" report including Super Crazy, Ricky Ortiz, The Dirty Sheet
CALDWELL'S ECW TV REPORT 9/2: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of WWE's Sci-Fi show
Arena Reports
8/31 WWE in St. Louis, Mo.: Full Raw and Smackdown taping results including final Unforgiven hype
8/24 WWE Smackdown in Canton, Ohio: Triple H & Undertaker vs. Khali & MVP, R-Truth vs. Carlito, Michelle vs. Maryse
8/24 TNA in Wichita, Ks.: Samoa Joe vs. A.J. Styles, Morgan vs. Kip, Knockouts Title Match, Lethal vs. Dutt
MMA / UFC Coverage
UFC News: Lesnar vs. Couture announced, Lesnar blasts legend, more MMA news and audio
UFC News: Paul Heyman comments on Brock Lesnar's controversial post-fight antics last Saturday
KELLER'S UFC 87 LIVE PPV REPORT; On-site ongoing coverage of Lesnar's second UFC fight, full card coverage
KELLER'S TAKE
VIP - KELLER: More crazy G.M. ideas for WWE to consider (PWTorch Newsletter #1037)
KELLER: An overhaul is in order for Raw before ratings drop further - several specific suggestions
KELLER: McMahon Returns for That? Nothing Funnier than a DUI! Let Me Shift So You Can Hit Me!
MITCHELL'S TAKE
MITCHELL'S BLOG: Notes From the 2008 NWA Fanfest - Ric Flair
WWE News: Flair's departure from WWE amicable, nostalgia convention circuit could be next
VIP - MITCHELL'S MEMO: DVD Liner Notes Part 3: Nature Boy Ric Flair - The Definitive Collection
MCNEILL'S TAKE
Ready To Roll! McNEILL previews WWE SummerSlam
Rap It Up: McNEILL previews TNA Hard Justice!
VIP - MCNEILL FACTOR: Twenty Years of Summerslam, part two
CALDWELL'S TAKE
CORNER CUBE THURSDAY 9/4 - Should I stay or should I go? Gail Kim's options
CORNER CUBE TUESDAY 9/2 - Thoughts on Raw with HBK-Jericho, Kane-Rey, and the next C.M. Punk
CORNER CUBE TUESDAY 8/26 - Raw delivered highlights, but was heavy on filler
RADICAN'S TAKE
TALES FROM THE PULPIT 9/5: TNA video game will succeed where promotion of PPVs ultimately fails
TALES FROM THE PULPIT 9/4: Nice days coming to TNA?
TALES FROM THE PULPIT 7/23: McGuinness & Jericho setting standard for heels in 2008
The Specialists
Nostalgia News: Former AWA wrestler Rick Renslow dies at age 53
CAREER PATH: Kurt Angle's career high point, low point, and what if he had never left WWE?
UNDER THE MICROSCOPE - 9/4 TNA IMPACT: What I noticed on the show that you might not have
Guest Editorials
EDITORIAL: What's wrong with Raw this year? A lot. But one core problem trumps the rest
EDITORIAL: Tag Team Divisions will not get over until squash matches return
EDITORIAL: C.M. Punk needs a prominent program to make him the star of Raw
Torch Feedback
WWE ECW Reax #1: "Striker's 'and vote Republican' was so awesome. Not because I am Republican, because I am certainly not, but..."
WWE Raw Reax #1: "The fire in Punk's eyes showed that those two could possibly have a meaningful fued later on."
DRAFT PICKS - Batch #7 featuring top picks of Chris Jericho, C.M. Punk, and Edge, plus Undertaker, Aries, Tomko, Briscoes...
Ask the Editor
Ask the Editor: Wouldn't incorporating MMA-style holds into pro wrestling matches just be trying to be something it's not?
ASK THE EDITOR: Have the Michaels-Batista promos crossed a line with use of insider terms, references to "jobs"?
ASK THE EDITOR: Why do wrestlers in WWE refer to wrestling as "the business" and not "the sport"?
DVDs - VGames - Books
WEEKEND DVD SPOTLIGHT: SHIMMER Vol. 18 (Kong-Busic,Del Rey-MsChif)
RADICAN: Al Snow discusses his wrestling career, philosophy, time in OVW, and more in new interview
DVD Review: ROH "Glory By Honor VI, N2" with Kenta vs. Misawa, 110307
Torch Flashbacks
KELLER'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 5 YRS. AGO (9-4-03):Angle vs. Taker, plus Rey, Vince, Stephanie, Brock, Big Show, Cena, APA
KELLER'S TNA REPORT 5 YRS. AGO (9-3-03): War Games-style ten man with D-Lo, Raven, Jeff Jarrett, plus Vince Russo on commentary
KELLER'S WWE RAW REPORT 5 YRS. AGO (9-1-03): Lawler vs. Coach, Christian vs. Jericho, Molly & Gail Kim vs. Trish & Ivory
VIP Exclusive Features
9/5 VIP East Coast Audio: Impact - An improvement over last week, Styles tells Sting what needed to be said (85 min.)
9/4 Daily Keller Hotline: Mickie James on dating and nude pics, Nash reminisces, Gail Kim & Foley Updates (5 min. free clip)
VIP - PWTorch Today Bulletin #15 (PDF): New Samoa Joe Interview Analysis, Nash Reminisces, Foley Note
Torch Trivia
Torch Trivia: How much do you know about Curt Henning? - Part One
Torch Trivia: How much do you know about Champion vs. Champion matches?
Torch Trivia: How much do you know about SummerSlam - Part 3
Torch Instant Polls
POLL: What are your thoughts on the WWE Championship Scramble concept?
POLL: Should the TNA Knockouts women wrestlers be paid in the same ballpark as the male wrestlers?
POLL: Who is your pick as the MVP of the August 11 edition of WWE Raw?
PWTorch Free Podcast
9/5 VIP East Coast Audio: Impact - An improvement over last week, Styles tells Sting what needed to be said (85 min.)
9/3 Nostalgia Audio: Nostalgia News, This week in wrestling history, WCW Monday Nitro
9/2 Daily Keller Hotline: Detailed analysis of Monday's Raw segment by segment (29 min.)
Annual Obituaries
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 1999 - Muchnick, Rick Rude, Owen Hart, Renegade...
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2000 - Solie, Albright, Duncum, Tsuruta, Blue Demon, Al Costello
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2001: Johnny Valentine, Terry Gordy, Chris Adams, Bertha Faye, Helen Hart