PWTORCH.COM
CONTACT USABOUT USFACEBOOKTWITTERPODCASTFREE IPHONE APPRSSVIP EXCLUSIVESVIP MEMBER LOG-INVIP SIGN-UP

CATEGORIES: WWE NEWS | TNA NEWS | WOMEN'S NEWS | OTHER NEWS | MMA & UFC NEWS | TORCH TODAY | INTERVIEWS | FREE AUDIO SHOWS
RAW REPORTS | SMACKDOWN REPORTS | IMPACT REPORTS | ROH TV REPORTS | ALL TV REPORTS | PPV REPORTS | ARENA REPORTS | FLASHBACKS


News Ticker
--- SMACKDOWN RESULTS: Swagger-Rey (CLICK HERE) --- NEWS & NOTES (CLICK HERE) --- SPOILERS: Aug. 6 episode (CLICK HERE)
--- AUG. 12 IMPACT: Spike TV announces full "fight card" line-up for TNA's post-Hardcore Justice PPV special (CLICK HERE)
--- IMPACT RESULTS: Dreamer-Abyss, new title in TNA, Best of Five continues, Hardcore Justice & "Impact special" build-up (CLICK HERE)
--- TNA SPOILERS: Summary of next four big shows (CLICK HERE) --- 8/2 RAW SPOILERS: Detailed report on next week's Raw (CLICK HERE)
--- SUMMERSLAM: Updated PPV card (CLICK HERE) --- RAW HOUSE SHOW: PWTorch staff on-site for WWE house show (CLICK HERE)
--- Vince McMahon interview on his WWE future (CLICK HERE) --- [Refresh to Update News or CLICK TO GO TO MAIN LISTING] ...

OPINION: KELLER | CALDWELL | MITCHELL | RADICAN | PARKS | MCNEILL | ASK THE EDITOR | READER REAX | POLLS | SPECIALISTS | DVDS & BOOKS

Search PWTorch




UGO AFFILIATE

A PROUD UGO AFFILIATE SINCE 1999


Listen to the PWTorch Livecast Mon-Fri Listen live or subscribe via iTunes

PWTorch Categories
PWTorch Main Listing
Staff Picks
NEWS REPORTS
PPV REPORTS
TV REPORTS
OPINION & ANALYSIS
THE SPECIALISTS
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
REFERENCE
PWTorch Free Podcast
VIP Exclusive Features

TV REPORTS

ECW ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 1/26: Caldwell, Donofrio, Parks rate and review

Jan 27, 2010 - 5:03:36 PM


James Caldwell, Torch Assistant Editor (6.5)

Good showing from the ECW brand leading to the Royal Rumble PPV. It was odd putting the ECW Title hype match in the opening match and the "young bucks" six-man tag in the main event, just like it was odd seeing DX in the opening segment on Raw and nowhere else the rest of the show. Nothing wrong with either, just odd based on DX being all over TV prior to this week's Raw and Christian-Zeke being the focus of TV for six weeks (if you include the Homecoming program building to Christian vs. Zeke). Perhaps WWE has some information that fans tune in to the beginning of ECW and tune out by the end of the show and WWE wanted to get the strong hype for the Rumble right out there at the top of the show.

As for the tag match, Kane was a good addition to the Christian vs. Regal & Jackson program. Jackson was made to look impressive up against another monster to make him more of an imposing threat to Christian at the Rumble, Christian took a pinfall loss to look in jeopardy of losing the belt on Sunday, and Jackson's star is being built in the process. No one believes Christian is dropping the belt on Sunday, but WWE executed basic booking here.

The six-man tag main event was solid for building up the young stars on the brand. It wasn't particularly memorable, but Yoshi stood out, Zack Ryder stood out as the top veteran on the heel team, and Croft & Barreta continue to get some good exposure.

Tony Donofrio, PWTorch.com Contributor (7.0)

This was a hard show to rate. It could have topped out at an 8.0 or bottomed out at a 6.0. So, using basic mathematical fundamentals, I gave it an average of a 7.0 (my junior high and HS teachers would be so damn proud). There were only two matches this week, but they were both quality matches. What's not to like about a one hour show giving you two quality matches with one solid interview segment and the Royal Rumble hype video (which just doesn't seem to get old). The only weak point for the show was really Shelton Benjamin's interview and the quick attack by Vance Archer...and that was a small miss, at that. The only thing that stopped this show from being higher is because, while the matches were solid, they weren't great. However, the quality of the matches weren't bad enough to pull the shows rating down either.

Seeing Ezekiel Jackson doing the brunt of the work in the opening match was a positive. He is vastly improved both in the ring and on the mic. Christian, William Regal, and Kane were all solid (as should be expected from three polished veterans) in the ring, as usual. The six man tag was another match that obviously won't be remembered in two weeks because, as I said, it wasn't exactly a 5 star classic. But again, solid work all around. This is a short review but because it was a quick, yet crisp, hour of wrestling programming, this is about all that needs to be said.

Greg Parks, Torch Columnist (6.0)

I'll be honest, the opening tag match really couldn't hold my attention. Perhaps I shouldn't have judged the book by its cover, but Kane and Ezekiel Jackson are two of my least-favorite in-ring performers in WWE at this point. Christian taking the loss made sense, as it gave Jackson that extra dose of credibility heading into the Royal Rumble. I did like Shelton Benjamin getting attacked by Vance Archer, usurping Benjamin's interview time. It was unique and simple enough to work.

The main event six-man tag was a solid outing for all six guys, who each got to look good at different times during the match. Yoshi Tatsu is finally growing on me, thanks in large part to his in-ring work. More importantly, the fans are getting behind him, a good thing for his future and for WWE. I'm still wondering what Croft & Baretta's long-term prospects are on ECW with no other tag teams on the brand.


Please take a moment to answer our demographic survey: CLICK HERE

Send feedback on this article to pwtorch@gmail.com and we'll regularly publish reader feedback in the "Torch Feedback" category on the Main Listing.


Upgrade to PWTorch VIP:

 DETAILS & SIGN-UP INFO (VIP Newsletter, Audio, Archives, No Ads on Website, VIP Email Reports, VIP Forum, more.)

For UFC & MMA NEWS & BLOGS:
VISIT OUR SISTER SITE - MMATORCH.COM

For more BREAKING NEWS on WWE, TNA...
VISIT OUR AFFILIATE - PROWRESTLING.NET

More Recent TV REPORTS Articles
PARKS' WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/30: Complete coverage of the Friday night show, including Swagger vs. Mysterio in a no-DQ match
KELLER'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/30: Kane reveals who put Undertaker in vegetative state, Swagger vs. Rey in no DQ match
KELLER'S TNA IMPACT REPORT 7/29: Tommy Dreamer announces new name for ECW faction, Hulk Hogan addresses situation
CALDWELL'S WWE SUPERSTARS RESULTS 7/29: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of MVP vs. Chavo Guerrero
WWE RAW ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 7/26: Caldwell, Mezzera, Parks rate and review
WWE NXT ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 7/27: Caldwell, Mayer, Parks rate and review
CALDWELL'S WWE NXT RESULTS 7/27: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of NXT Season 2, Week 8
KELLER'S WWE RAW REPORT 7/26: Follow-up on Team Cena forming, Summerslam hype including new stips for Nexus tag match
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 7/26: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Raw on USA Network hyping Summerslam
PARKS' WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/23: Complete coverage of the Friday night show, including Swagger vs. Mysterio, 2-out-of-3 falls for a Summerslam Title Shot
KELLER'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/23: Kane celebrates his victory, Rey Mysterio vs. Jack Swagger best of three falls for no. 1 contendership
KELLER'S TNA IMPACT REPORT 7/22: Follow up on big ECW Invasion angle including Dixie Carter's involvement
WILKENFELD'S TNA IMPACT REPORT 7/22: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Spike TV broadcast [updated]
CALDWELL'S WWE SUPERSTARS RESULTS 7/22: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of Hart Dynasty vs. Usos, Mr. Superstars in action
CALDWELL'S WWE NXT RESULTS 7/20: Complete "virtual time" coverage of NXT Season 2, Week 7
WWE RAW ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 7/19: Caldwell, Donofrio, Parks rate and review
WWE RAW RESULTS 7/19: Keller's complete coverage of live Money in the Bank fallout
CALDWELL'S WWE RAW RESULTS 7/19: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of live Raw following Money in the Bank PPV
HITS & MISSES - WWE MITB PPV 7/18: Kane wins MITB and World Title, Sheamus vs. Cena, Look-ahead to Summerslam
KELLER'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/16: Lousy announcing dampens big angle at close of final pitch for MITB PPV

 

Staff Picks - Top Ten Articles
TNA News: TNA Impact rating for Thursday's show, detailed demographic break down, Analysis of what likely "popped" the rating
WWE News: Smackdown Results - IC Title match next week, Women's Title result, Summerslam line-up
Other News: Former WWE wrestler Carlito Colon signed for MTV's next "Lucha Libre USA" TV taping
TNA News: Spike TV announces full line-up for TNA's "Impact special" on August 12
TNA News: Impact Results - New title in TNA, Best of Five series, Fortune group, KO Title #1 contender
WWE News: SPOILERS - Big News & Notes from Smackdown TV taping for August 6 episode
WWE News: NXT ratings - detailed report on TV viewership for Tuesday's elimination episode
MCNEILL'S VIP BLOG: Booking TNA's Hardcore Justice PPV
TNA News: SPOILERS - top matches scheduled to air on next two Impacts, Hardcore Justice PPV, Impact "special"
WWE News: Raw ratings are in for Monday night's show



PWTorch Free Audio Shows
FREE: Friday PWTorch Livecast (7/30) now available featuring James Caldwell & Brian Hoops
FREE: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/29) now available featuring James Caldwell & Greg Parks
FREE: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/28) now available featuring Wade Keller & Pat McNeill
FREE: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (7/27) now available featuring Wade Keller & Jason Powell
FREE: Monday PWTorch Livecast (7/26) now available featuring James Caldwell & Bruce Mitchell
FREE: Friday PWTorch Livecast (7/23) now available featuring Wade Keller & Bruce Mitchell

PWTorch Free Audio Shows

SUMMERSLAM POLL: Where do you see The Undertaker fitting into the Summerslam PPV?
Kane vs. Rey Mysterio vs. Taker three-way match
Involved in Kane vs. Rey Mysterio
No. 1 contender match vs. Jack Swagger/other opponent
Match/storyline with C.M. Punk & SES
Off the PPV line-up
  




SUMMERSLAM POLL: Which match do you consider the "top match" of this year's Summerslam PPV?
Sheamus vs. Randy Orton
Team Cena vs. Team Nexus
Kane vs. Rey Mysterio
  




SUMMERSLAM POLL: What is your current interest level in ordering the Summerslam PPV?
Very interested - storylines are peaking at the right time
Interested - top matches for Summerslam seem strong
Interested - want to see how the rest of the card fills out
Undecided - need to see more of the PPV build-up
Not sold - not a strong-enough sales pitch yet
No interest - won't be ordering the PPV no matter the line-up
  



UndertakerArt_130GG_40.jpg
VOTE IN OR SEE RESULTS OF PREVIOUS POLLS

Upcoming Event Schedule

Articles Grouped by Category
NEWS REPORTS
7/30 PWG results in Reseda, Calif.: Complete real-time coverage of PWG anniversary show - Bryan Danielson, GenMe, Davey Richards vs. Chris Hero
TNA News: TNA Impact rating for Thursday's show, detailed demographic break down, Analysis of what likely "popped" the rating
WWE News: Smackdown Results - IC Title match next week, Women's Title result, Summerslam line-up
WWE/TNA News: Weekend WWE & TNA show previews; Reports Wanted
Other News: Former WWE wrestler Carlito Colon signed for MTV's next "Lucha Libre USA" TV taping
TNA News: TNA Impact viewership for Thursday's show - highest in five months
PPV REPORTS
WWE MONEY IN THE BANK RESULTS 7/18: Keller's complete coverage of live PPV event with John Cena vs. Sheamus
CALDWELL'S WWE MONEY IN THE BANK PPV RESULTS 7/18: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of live PPV
TNA VICTORY ROAD RESULTS 7/11: Keller's ongoing "virtual time" coveage of live PPV event
CALDWELL'S TNA VICTORY ROAD PPV RESULTS 7/11: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage live on-site from Orlando - four-way TNA Title match, Flair vs. Lethal
RADICAN'S DGUSA "UPRISING" PPV REVIEW: Shingo & Yamato vs. Kid & CIMA, PAC & Doi vs. Quackenbush & Jigsaw
WWE FATAL 4-WAY PPV RESULTS: Keller's complete report on Cena vs. Sheamus vs. Orton vs. Edge, Swagger vs. Rey vs. Show vs. Punk
TV REPORTS
PARKS' WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/30: Complete coverage of the Friday night show, including Swagger vs. Mysterio in a no-DQ match
KELLER'S WWE SMACKDOWN REPORT 7/30: Kane reveals who put Undertaker in vegetative state, Swagger vs. Rey in no DQ match
KELLER'S TNA IMPACT REPORT 7/29: Tommy Dreamer announces new name for ECW faction, Hulk Hogan addresses situation
CALDWELL'S WWE SUPERSTARS RESULTS 7/29: Ongoing "virtual time" coverage of MVP vs. Chavo Guerrero
WWE RAW ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 7/26: Caldwell, Mezzera, Parks rate and review
WWE NXT ROUNDTABLE REVIEWS 7/27: Caldwell, Mayer, Parks rate and review
OPINION & ANALYSIS
KELLER'S VIP BLOG: Topics - Kane's revelation and what was missing from tonight's angle, new Impact ratings insight that could halt any ECW celebration, Ross opens door to returning to weekly TV
TNA Impact Reax #1 and RADICAN responds to reader feedback on TNA's ECW-themed PPV
KELLER'S VIP BLOG: How to turn Rob Terry into the hottest act in wrestling
KELLER'S VIP BLOG: Creating an ECW vs. TNA Dream Card with help of a time machine
MCNEILL'S VIP BLOG: Booking TNA's Hardcore Justice PPV
KELLER'S VIP BLOG: The best and worst case scenarios for TNA-ECW angle
THE SPECIALISTS
7/27 WWE NXT Hits & Misses: Mic Time for the Rookies, Cottonwood - Morrison, Cottonwood Eliminated
7/26 WWE Raw Hits & Misses: Orton Interview, Orton Squashes Uso, Nexus Dominates
HITS & MISSES - ROH TV on HDNet 7/26: ROH tag champs surprised by Ninjas, Christopher Daniels vs. Roderick Strong, Necro as a heel
7/23 WWE Smackdown Hits & Misses: Kane's Promo, Christian & Hardy vs. McIntyre & Rhodes, Ziggler vs. Kingston, Swagger vs. Mysterio
7/22 WWE Superstars Hits & Misses: MVP & Masters, Uso Brothers vs. The Hart Dynasty
ABSURDITY OF IT ALL - TNA: "One Night Stand" - Sponsored by TNA, What Are Jarrett And Nash Talking About?, Oh, Sting Was Talking About "Inception," Not Deception
PWTORCH EXCLUSIVES
RADICAN'S ROH DVD REVIEW SERIES: "Supercard of Honor V": KOW-MCMG, Black-Strong
SUMMERSLAM 1995 PPV FLASHBACK: Interesting facts from Summerslam 15 years ago - wrestlers in WWE, TNA, out of wrestling; Top-rated matches
SUMMERSLAM 2000 PPV FLASHBACK: Interesting facts from Summerslam ten years ago - wrestlers in WWE, TNA, out of wrestling; Top-rated matches, Kane vs. Taker
WWE RAW 7/26: Place Your Bets on tonight's Raw - Week 17 with Summerslam hype
WWE RAW 7/19: "Place your Bets" Scoreboard after Week 16 - Review last week's scores before this week's Raw
TORCH FLASHBACK: July 2000 - Which WWE wrestlers were viewed as future top stars ten years ago?
REFERENCE
5/16 TNA Stats in Review: Current champions, 2010 Win/Loss Records, TV & PPV & house show results
5/3 TNA Stats in Review: Current champions, 2010 Win/Loss Records, TV & PPV & house show results
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 1999 - Muchnick, Rick Rude, Owen Hart, Renegade...
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2000 - Solie, Albright, Duncum, Tsuruta, Blue Demon, Al Costello
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2001: Johnny Valentine, Terry Gordy, Chris Adams, Bertha Faye, Helen Hart
SPECIALIST: List of Deceased Wrestlers for 2002 (Wahoo, Thesz, Rocco, Mr. Wrestling)
PWTorch Free Podcast
FREE: Friday PWTorch Livecast (7/30) now available featuring James Caldwell & Brian Hoops
FREE: Thursday PWTorch Livecast (7/29) now available featuring James Caldwell & Greg Parks
FREE: Wednesday PWTorch Livecast (7/28) now available featuring Wade Keller & Pat McNeill
FREE: Tuesday PWTorch Livecast (7/27) now available featuring Wade Keller & Jason Powell
FREE: Monday PWTorch Livecast (7/26) now available featuring James Caldwell & Bruce Mitchell
FREE: Friday PWTorch Livecast (7/23) now available featuring Wade Keller & Bruce Mitchell
VIP Exclusive Features
VIP - 7/30 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Ross on returning to Raw, Smackdown thoughts, Kane's revelation, Impact ratings pop, Carlito signed, Shelley injury, Lucha USA extended, PWG, Heenan update, more (20 min.)
VIP - 7/30 PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow: James Caldwell & Brian Hoops discuss awful Impact & strong ratings, TV Title, WWE HOF, Summerslam, Carlito news, Heenan, Ross (72 min.)
VIP - 7/30 Bruce Mitchell Audio Show (pt. 1): Pros and cons of Percy Watson, should Cena critique NXT wrestlers on Twitter, vegan wrestlers, is Vince McMahon to Linda what Bill Clinton was to Hilary, McMahon's childhood (58 min.)
VIP - 7/29 Wade Keller Hotline - The News: Shawn Michaels joins Internet, NXT ratings, Linda opponent fires shots, Dixie counters a rumor, Mikey Whipwreck on Hardcore Justice, Ross responds to Cole's dig (14 min.)
VIP - 7/29 PWTorch Livecast & VIP Aftershow: James Caldwell & Greg Parks discuss Impact tonight, Hogan, tangled webs of confusing storylines, Linda, HBK, Nexus, NXT (78 min.)
VIP - 7/28 East Coast Audio - NXT: Eli eliminated, Husky-Kaval, Promo time, Husky up & Percy down (90 min.)
© 1999-2010 TDH Communications Inc. • All rights reserved. -- PRIVACY POLICY